Tire Recommendations

Hey everyone, I’ve done a bit of research but I’m hoping to get some individual opinions on a replacement tire for the stock Geolanders I currently have on my 2021 Crosstrek.

I’ve got 46K miles on my tires and they’re looking a little less than ideal.

Here are my driving conditions:

Most of the driving I do is highway commuting back-and-forth to work, I drive about 200 miles per week on the highway so efficiency matters to me. (I usually avg 32MPG at the pump!)

I go to the snow two or so times per year, so having the ability to drive in snow is important, but certainly not the main concern. Similarly, I like to take my car on dirt roads and the occasional fire Road now and then, but this is also not too often, so not a major concern there either.

What’s my best bet? Should I just replace the Geolanders with a new set or should I go for something different? Thanks in advance for the input!