Scalding hot take: Let MAGA dismantle federal redistributive programs

Debate

This is more thought experiment than practical proposal.

There is a paradox in U.S. politics. Red states generally receive more aid from the federal government than they pay in, while sending representatives to weaken the federal programs that they benefit from. The bulk of net contributions are made from blue states: Massachusetts, California, Washington, and New Jersey. The majority of blue states are either net contributors or roughly equal in what they receive and pay in. The only state that voted Trump in 2024 to pay in more than it received was Utah. Its contributions only outweighed its receipts by a small margin.

So, let's get rid of social security, federal spending for Medicare, Medicaid/ACA, agricultural subsidies/SNAP and other transfers to states. We can replace these federal programs with state funded programs that accomplish the same goals of supporting healthcare, retirement, and relieving poverty. The high-earning blue states can provide direct transfers to residents of less productive states as well as to their own residents.

On the downside, state programs probably would not be as generous as current benefits for residents of red states, because the federal government can run deficits. However, this could cut federal spending in half, saving roughly $3.5T a year. This would enable a budget surplus and give the Federal Reserve flexibility to lower interest rates. These improvements would allow greater productivity which can offset some of the loss for red state residents.

I don't want to see people in red states suffer, but there is a moral hazard in using the federal government to transfer funds to GOP-run governments. Funding a government reinforces the status quo and disincentivizes conservatives from reforming their own institutions to become self-sufficient. Red states receive the benefits of liberalism while maintaining a reactionary culture that hinders productivity.

Posted Mar 10, 2025, 9:41 PM UTC

2279

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 79 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.