Premed Date Lying About MCAT? Red flag??

A few weeks ago I met a girl on a dating app and I took her out. We immediately connected because we started to talk about the MCAT and Anki decks. She was just about to write her exam, and I was very impressed and thought she was intelligent because her scores on her recent practice tests were 523, 521, and 528. There was a bit of a red flag though, because a couple of guys kept calling/texting her during the date and it made me feel a little disrespected. She assured me they were stalker exes that she wanted nothing to do with and that she preferred my company.

Understandably I haven’t spoken to her since she went off to study and write the exam. Anyway, I ran into her again recently and saw her actual score was a 493 on her laptop screen. This hit me hard, because it suggested I might not actually know this girl at all. It’s not so much that I may have overstated her abilities, it’s more that she is dishonest? If she lied about her MCAT scores, what else is a lie? Is she lying about her exes too?

P/S section of the MCAT doesn’t rly offer guidance for this scenario. Are my fears justified? Or am I just being paranoid?