Looking to experiment with slow cooking. Seeking advice/warnings.

I really like to experiment when I cook, occasional eschewing recipes and convention to try and come up with my own thing. Throwing together lots of crazy things to try and find something unique that really fits my particular tastes.

I was wondering if you all had any general advice or warnings for experimenting with slow cooking.

What kinds of things should I definitely not put in a slow cooker, either due to taste or safety concerns? What are some interesting or unintuitive combos you've come across first hand? That kind of stuff.

Posted Aug 14, 2013, 4:03 PM UTC

209
whateveryousayboss•

I tried to be positive about this, but all I could come up with a list of don'ts.

  • Don't slow cook without a crock-pot liner. Clean up is a snap.

  • Don't fill it to the top. Clean up will not be a snap.

  • Don't stir the pot. I know it's tempting, but set it and forget it.

  • Don't add dairy ingredients until the tail end of cooking time.

  • Don't throw a whole chicken in there thinking everything will be fine.

6
shutz2•

I've cooked a whole chicken and got great results. You just have to know what you're doing. I brined the chicken overnight, then set it on a bed of onion halves, sprinkled some spice rub on the chicken, and didn't add any liquid. The brining prevents the meat from drying up, and the onions prevent it from soaking in the juices too much. It's also a good idea to have at least 2 hours of the cooking done on High, to increase the "roasting" effect.

4
capnjack78•

Adding liquid turned out to be my problem. I made several chickens before realising the reason it was too soft/mushy was because I added water to the pot when it wasn't needed at all. I've never brined it ahead of time though, but I do add seasoning under the skin. And I put a quartered onion and several cloves of garlic in there too.

2
shutz2•

Brining flavors the meat, and causes more moisture to remain in the meat, so that you don't need to add any liquid.

My "recipe" for brine:

  • 8-12 cups of water
  • 1/4 to 1/2 cup of kosher salt (do not use iodized salt, or you'll taste the iodine in the meat.)
  • 1/4 to 1/2 cup of brown sugar (or table sugar, or better yet, maple syrup)
  • About 1 TBSP of whole peppercorns (I use Tellicherry Pepper, but you can try others.)
  • 6-8 whole allspice (these look like large peppercorns)

Heat up the water on the stove, and while it's heating up, add the other ingredients. Stir until all the salt and sugar have dissolved. Turn off the heat, and let the brine cool off. If you don't have time, put the pot in your sink, and run cool water beside it, moving the pot around to help transfer the heat to the surrounding water faster.

Once the brine is at room temperature or cooler, put your meat in. There should be enough water to almost cover all the meat. If you don't have enough brine, consider adding a few heavy but empty containers around the meat to take up some volume.

Put the pot with the brining meat in the fridge and leave it there for at least 12 hours. I wouldn't go past 24 hours, unless you're trying to make something more akin to deli meat.

Also, after the chicken (this also works great with a pork roast) is done and you've taken it out of the slow-cooker, the remaining juices and onions (and garlic, if applicable) make for a really wonderful gravy.
Here's how I make it:

  • Using a hand mixer, purée the contents left at the bottom of your slow-cooker. This will be a meat-seasoned onion purée, more or less.
  • Transfer this purée to a pot on your stove.On the side, mix about 1 cup of water with your favorite gravy thickening agent. For a saltier and more flavorful gravy, I use something called "Bisto", and when I just want to thicken, I use something called "Veloutine" but I'm from Québec, so I have no idea what you might find at the supermarket. Cornstarch should work well.
  • If you're using an unflavored thickener, you might want add a little salt & pepper.
  • Bring to a boil, then simmer for 3-5 minutes, until it's thick like gravy.

Tastes great on mashed potatoes or fries.

3
Maverick814•

Never have even heard of a liner. I'll definitely have to check these out. My crock pots can get real disgusting with the things I put in it.

3
capnjack78•

I love crock pot liners, but only for really messy things like BBQ or tomato sauce, which seems to burn around the top edge.

Someone might comment here saying they're toxic, but truth is the temperature in the pot won't be able to get high enough to break down the liner chemically to affect the food. We've had several threads about that topic and I thought it was worth mentioning.

1
GrandmaGos•

Don't fill it to the top. Clean up will not be a snap.

This times 100. If you fill it up all the way with liquid, it WILL bubble over and WILL get wetness all over the counter.

1
capnjack78•

DO put everything in the slow cooker. There is nothing that I have thought of that I couldn't find a recipe for by searching in this sub or on allrecipes. You can even make bread and cake in it! Flakey fish seems to be the only thing that gets really obliterated in a crock pot, but even that is fine in a stew.

1
finebydesign•

My biggest advice is:

  1. Avoid the high setting
  2. get a timer
  3. get America's Test Kitchen slowcooker revolution cookbook and use that for rules.
1