Carribean resort or pop and time frame.

So I been eyeing the crowd calendar for 2026 and I know it's far out but it has mixed reviews for the times we are thinking of going. We are thinking either Tuesday January 27 to Tues feb 3, or February 3 to February 10th. Both times show average crowds to higher crowds on weekends to both weekends having cheer competitions. So I guess my question is there is only a 400 dollar difference between the resort. What resort would you choose and also what time frame do you think may be better end of January or beginning of February? Also if anyone been at the parks and resort during cheer time what was your experience like.