Would you rather the musical or book ending for wicked

For reference I have read the book, but only seen the musical once I didn’t really like part 2. I would personally like the book ending for the movie where elphaba sends hordes of animal and her friends kill all of them.

Although I am pretty sure that they will stick to the musical because they will need to do a lot of set up for all the pieces to work but I would personally find it more interesting. Also I know it won’t be like this because this scene is only in the original book non the MGM movie.

Also, I totally think they will reveal that elphaba is alive in the end. I think it would be kinda cheap and unnecessary as having elphaba dying for good is a lot more poignant.

Also also, I hope that they make nessarose evil, because I never felt she was that bad of person besides cursing the tin man.

(This might be a messy post I just wanted to get my thoughts across quickly)