Neutral Transaction Broker Charging 5% of Purchase Price - Normal?
Hello everyone,
My GF and I have rented our home for a little over 3 years. The owner was a sweet person who was renting our home to us through a property management company. Sadly, the owner passed away earlier this year.
Our property management company emailed us and told us the owner's children were interested in selling the house and wanted to know if we were interested in buying. They also offered to be a transaction broker for us and for the owners. We told the property management company we were interested and have been taking all the necessary steps for the purchase. I am an attorney and my GF took real estate classes so we figured we could do this without a real estate agent.
Today, our property management company emailed us an "Exclusive Right-to-Buy Listing Contract" for both myself and my GF with the company. They will be charging a success fee of 5% of the purchase price. To who they will be charging is unclear. One provision of the contract states "Seller will be responsible for agent compensation" and another that states "Buyer is obligated to pay any portion of the Success Fee which is not paid by the seller's brokerage firm or seller, but only if Broker discloses to Buyer the amount Buyer must pay, in writing and prior to Buyer entering into a contract with the seller." To me, that indicates that seller is presumed to pay the cost but they can ask to offset some of the cost to us. Which makes sense.
However, is 5% for a transaction broker normal? To me it seems high but I am not sure. We do not have a buyer's agent, I do not know if the owners have a seller's agent either but I would guess not. I know typically seller's expect to pay 5-6% of the purchase price but that includes the commission for both agents. I am worried the seller's may use the above-mentioned clauses to offset some of the costs to us given that they are paying 5% without the luxury of having their own advocate. And I am worried we will wind up paying basically the same amount we would have had we just gone with our own agents.
It just seems high given that they are not meant to be our advocate nor the advocate for the owners. To me, it seems that if neither seller nor buyer get the luxury of an advocate, then the cost for the brokerage should probably be less than your typical 2-agent transaction. But I honestly do not know and Google is not helping.
Posted Jun 10, 2025, 8:21 PM UTC