Progressive Payments

My insurance payment was supposed to come out on 06/06, (it didn't) and I even checked the status on the progressive app to which it said "thank you for your payment on 06/06- next payment 07/06". I got a notification it declined my card on 06/10 due to insufficient funds, because I had spent money thinking my insurance was already paid like it said. Anyway, I went ahead and made a manual payment on 06/10 and even read on here that it wouldn't try to take the money again if I made a manual payment. This morning I got an email that progressive has tried to charge my card AGAIN for this month (declined again, of course) even when I have already made a payment and both progressive and my bank say I made the payment 3 days ago. Why are they charging me more when I've already paid?