r/nba•
Terry_Pandee

Who was the better player last season, Kobe or Melo?

I was debating a couple people earlier and found that a number of people thought that Melo was the better player last season. It was between a Knick fan and myself being a Laker fan, I wanted to get some unbiased opinions. I can concede that Melo was a better scorer by a slight margin but I see him as one dimensional, I don't see what he brings other than scoring ability. Kobe, though a scorer first, is still a great all around player.

Edit: I think people are interpreting the question as "who was the better MVP candidate last season". I'm seeing a lot of responses talking about the Knicks were better so Melo was better, that's not what I was asking. I'm asking if all things equal do you believe that Melo is now a better basketball player than Kobe? I'm not factoring in team success like you would with the MVP award, just looking at 2 individual players and asking whose play did you prefer last season.

Posted Sep 3, 2013, 3:41 AM UTC · edited

1663
Loading comments…