Interesting Fact Regarding The Penalty For Not Honoring Alliances

EU4

If you have an ally who won't join your war for any reason, who then turns around and calls you to arms in the middle of your war, if you leave the accept/refuse dialog up, open their country view and call them to arms & wait for them to refuse, you can refuse their call to arms without penalty. The alliance is broken(would have been on your refusal anyway), but you don't take the -25 hit to prestige.

You both get the dishonored alliance/refused to join our war relationship penalty against each other, though.

Posted Sep 3, 2013, 11:12 PM UTC

711
tiloup1441•

Also, random tip, sometimes when you start the war it will say your ally will not join the war. However, if the ally of the person you are declaring war on is the rival of your ally, he will join if you call him after the war started.

I.E i was naples with france as ally, attacked tuscany with austria as ally. france would not join me vs tuscany but since austria was their rival, once they joined the war vs me france accepted the call to arms

8
eranam•

Well, that's a bit gamey isn't it?

2
Code_For_FoodOP•

Yes and no. I try to not just exploit things when I play, but here's my rational for why it's not that gamey: If it was in multiplayer between two humans talking ahead of time, it would be the equivalent of one saying, "Wait, you want me to support your war but you're unwilling to support mine? I'll make you a deal. Help in my war and I'll agree to help you."

In that regard, it seems gamey that the AI, when unwilling to support me in a war, can pretty much screw me right after by forcing me to either support his stupid dreams of conquest or take a massive prestige hit. There should really be a mechanism in place to prevent allies who won't support you in wars from demanding your help(at the very least, no prestige loss, although now that I think about it, it's possible that mechanism is in place and that's what I saw when I did this last night).

2
attrition0A King of Europa•

I don't see this as too gamey as I rationalize it like this:

Join my war!

Uh how about you join one of my thirteen wars going on right now

No

Well then stuff it

2
MChainsawVictorian Emperor•

Wait, so the alliance is only broken if the player declines the call, but if the AI does the alliance is still maintained?

2
Mallard_King•

no, if you refuse a call you get a penalty for breaking the alliance, since technically the AI refused the call first, they broke the alliance

4
Code_For_FoodOP•

No, it's broken when the AI does, but he takes the hit, not you. It doesn't remove the Call To Arms dialog box even though the alliance is now gone, though. That stays up until you either click it or it times out and auto-declines.

2
MChainsawVictorian Emperor•

But I'm confused, in the scenario you described, didn't you mean that you had an ally, then you got involved in a war and called your ally to war, but they declined, but then later they got into a war and called you, which they shouldn't be able to do if the alliance was already broken? Or did you mean that they didn't join for some other reason, like if the alliance pact was signed after you started your war or if you got into your war in the first place by answering the call of another ally?

2
Code_For_FoodOP•

Ah, I understand the question now. No. I didn't call them because it told me they wouldn't accept(red X on choice, mouseover text said that they were at like -1000 towards joining due to their lack of a decent army at that point and some other reasons, so wasn't possible) & at that point I didn't want to break the alliance.

2
MChainsawVictorian Emperor•

Okay I see. Actually I think the alliance system is a little too simple in that respect. Like, I can see how the alliance would be broken and you'd get a prestige hit if you declined a call to arms while you yourself were at peace with a perfectly healthy and capable army ready to fight, since you really have no good reason not to honour the alliance. But if you're already involved in three different wars, your army is either obliterated or tied up in battles at the other side of the world and your ecomony is failing, then there should be an option to say "Sorry dude, I would love to help you but I really, really can't right now" and you'd be able to decline the call without suffering penalties.

2