Anonymous Dreams and Equestrian Screams Afterparty #1 - Diamond and Silver Devastation
A few months ago, a human woke up in Equestria with a splitting headache and a kind, concerned pony tending to him.
Unfortunately for the ponies, the human thinks he's dreaming.
Doubly unfortunately, he's a sadistic snuff freak who's been beating off to the thought of raping and murdering ponies for a decade, and he thinks this is a harmless, consequence-free place to indulge his fantasies.
The Mane Six have been slaughtered mercilessly, along with Princess Celestia and Princess Luna, only to be brought back by Celestia's magical machinations. Now things are changing in Equestria in ways some ponies find alarming, and Silver Spoon and her lover Diamond Tiara, all grown up, have been summoned to Canterlot...
(MLP, human/pony, suffocation impalement, orientation play/corrective rape.)
The characterizations here are based on wiki dives, watching a few clips, and pony R34 content. I'd love to hear how accurate the characters/voices are, and who you'd like to see snuffed next.
Inspired in many ways by this series of MLP songs I stumbled on.
Chapter 1: Fluttershy's Brutal Anal Extermination.
Chapter 2: Pinkie Pie's Fatal Throatfuck.
Chapter 3: Applejack Spills Her Guts.
Chapter 5: Rainbow Dash's Hell Rape
Chapter 6: Triple Princess Buttslut Slaughter
Silver Spoon shifted her rump uncomfortably on the sparkling tiles of the Canterlot courtyard. She felt uncomfortable – physically, socially, mentally.
Things had been very strange in Equestria lately. She kept hearing about some strange naked ape that was walking around like he owned the place. And the princesses weren’t being their normal punctual selves – the sun and moon were frequently off-schedule, like Celestia and Luna had something distracting them.
And now Silver Spoon and Diamond Tiara had been invited, cordially but firmly, to visit Canterlot.
And Diamond Tiara was… somewhere. Seeing the princesses, supposedly.
And Silver Spoon was waiting.
She sipped an iced juice that one of the palace staff had supplied her and sighed.
She’d been to Canterlot plenty of times before, of course. She came from money, after all, and there were plenty of reasons for her mother to visit the capital with Silver Spoon in tow. It was different visiting as a just-barely-adult mare, though, and especially by royal decree.
And extra-especially when her lover had been taken for an audience and she was being kept waiting.
It still brought a thrill of excitement to Silver Spoon’s heart when she thought of it – Diamond Tiara, her lover. Her marefriend. Her special somepony.
Both of them had dated stallions in the past, in fact they had lost their cherries together on the same double-date, holding each other’s hooves as two studs who may as well have been nameless plowed away recklessly. Silver Spoon felt a pool of liquid heat in her belly as she thought of that night – staring into Diamond Tiara’s beautiful eyes, watching the pleasure there, feeling it herself as she was fucked full of hard cock but getting far more enjoyment from her best friend’s sexy reactions.
She had orgasmed so hard watching Diamond Tiara watch her get fucked.
That was the first night they’d kissed, and the stallions thought they had won the lottery, but it was also the last night either Silver Spoon or Diamond Tiara went on a date with anypony but each other.
Silver Spoon still thought of herself as bisexual, but Diamond Tiara had firmly declared herself a mares-only mare for life.
With a fierce blush, Silver Spoon realized that her pussy had grown wet and tingling. She jumped to her feet, not wanting to leave a shiny trace of her arousal on the pristine pavement.
Somepony tapped her on the shoulder with his hoof, and she screamed and kicked her juice over by accident as she turned.
“The princesses will see you now,” the guard said, keeping his face carefully neutral, but Silver Spoon could see the amusement in his eyes. Ducking her head, she followed him into the palace proper.
Cool colonnades led in to great doorways, and as she disappeared into the dark entrance she thought she could hear a faint, rhythmic slapping sound. She frowned. Surely nopony would be having sex just… out and about in the palace, would they?
Ahead of her, the guard pushed open a fancy door, and the slapping got louder. Silver Spoon felt apprehension growing in the pit of her stomach, resting uneasily there mingled with her heated desires.
“Sir, what is that noise?” she asked, brows furrowing. “Is everything okay?”
In answer, he ushered her past him into a large, lavish sitting room. She walked in, and her heart cracked in two.
On her belly on a small, upholstered bench, Diamond Tiara, blindfolded and gagged, was sweating and rocking as a hairless monkey-thing – a human, that’s what they called him, a man-human – fucked her from behind. He was pounding her pussy fast, her tail in his right hand, her mane in his left, her butt shaking from the force of his cock-strokes.
Seeing her enter, the monster unbuckled Diamond Tiara’s gag, and immediately the hard-fucked mare’s sounds of raw pleasure filled the room.
“You like getting fucked, don’t you, you slutty pony?” he said, staring at Silver Spoon.
“Yes! Oh, Celestia I’ve missed it!” Diamond Tiara moaned. “It’s so good!”
A tear stung Silver Spoon’s left eye, broke over to roll down her cheek, smearing the makeup Diamond Tiara had helped her apply that morning.
There was a faint twinkle of magic around Diamond Tiara’s head, and Silver Spoon dimly realized that Princess Celestia and Princess Luna were also in the room – elegantly seated on smaller versions of their thrones, each with a forehoof between her sister’s legs rubbing insistently and making their hips twitch.
Princess Celestia telekinetically twitched Diamond Tiara’s blindfold away, and the pink pony shrieked at the sight of her broken-hearted marefriend.
“I don’t know… I don’t know how this happened!” she whined. “I l-love you!”
“How can you say that?” Silver Spoon screamed at her. “Y-you’re letting that animal rut you like a whore!”
“It isn’t my fault!” Diamond Tiara said, grunting as he tightened his grip on her hair, turning her head to one side. “I’m… I didn’t...”
“Your little friend looks pretty sad about this,” the human said. He dropped Diamond Tiara’s tail and gently probed her butthole with his thumb. “Just look at her. I think you broke her heart. Letting a strange man pummel your guts like this. Such a little slut.”
“Stop saying those things!” Silver Spoon and Diamond Tiara said at the same time – Silver Spoon’s tone shattered and raw, Diamond Tiara’s tinged with sick lust at the fire the human was stoking in her.
Gentle arms of alicorn magic pushed Silver Spoon closer to the lewd scene, until she was face to face with her lover, staring at her straining, conflicted face.
It was so much like that sexy, thrilling double date, but the feelings tearing through Silver Spoon’s heart now were far from the blossoming romantic affection she’d felt then.
“Please… don’t… hate me!” Diamond Tiara panted. “I’m… I’m…” Her face was scrunching up, her breath coming in sharp gasps, and with horror and a sudden hate Silver Spoon knew that Diamond Tiara was about to cum.
As the man thrust his thumb up Diamond Tiara’s tight pony asshole, the pink pony squeezed her eyes shut, her body tensing, thighs shaking as she reached a pussy-throbbing orgasm on his massive human cock.
Grunting as he neared his own climax, he pulled out, stepped forward, and gave himself a few strokes before his balls tightened and he shot thick white ropes of stick human semen all over Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon’s faces – Silver Spoon’s locked into a stricken expression of loss, Diamond Tiara’s relaxing into a fuck-drunk pleasure mask.
“How could you do this to me?” Silver Spoon asked the man, sitting back on her haunches. “Why would you do this? I… I never did anything to you!”
“You shouldn’t have shacked up with such a pony who’s such a slut for dick,” he said. “I mean, you mares are kind of all the same, but still.”
“No we’re not!” she bristled, but before she could do anything he was behind her, his left arm looped under her forelegs, his right diving between her thighs to grip her hot little pussy tightly.
“Stop that!” she whimpered. “I’m not… I don’t want this!”
His fingers – Sweet Celestia she’d never felt anything like those amazing squirmy appendages! Stroking, probing, circling her clit!
Her jaw clenched hard, her body tensing up, her face a quivering mess of tears, cum, and ruined makeup as she fought the feelings that were building inside her, threatening to overwhelm her nervous system.
No wonder Diamond Tiara had broken so easily.
Oh fuck, oh my stars, oh Celestia!
Celestia was right there, just yards away, drinking in the scene with a serene smile as she and her sister pleasured each other. They were using their magic now, sparkling fields of telekinetic force stimulating their horny marehoods as they enjoyed the debauching of the two earth ponies.
They were enjoying it.
Silver Spoon let out a low cry, her body rolling against her will, grinding her enslaved pussy against the hand that was sending such incredible thrills through her young body.
It wasn’t fair.
It wasn’t fair that this creature should appear out of nowhere to steal her Diamond Tiara away.
It wasn’t fair that he could make her feel these horrible things, wasn’t fair that he’d marked their faces with his awful spunk.
It wasn’t fair that her divine princesses, who should have protected her and Diamond Tiara, were masturbating their stupid slutty cunts instead.
And just at that moment, the thing that felt the very most unfair was that she was about to climax and there was nothing she could do about it.
She opened her eyes and looked at Diamond Tiara, laying on the bench looking exhausted and satisfied and horribly guilty.
As she looked, she felt her pussy clench and her clit zap a lightning-shock sensation through her body, and her mouth dropped open, a stupid expression of braindead lust covering her face as she came in his arms like a worthless little cumdump.
“Told you so,” he whispered in her ear, tossing her onto the floor.
She couldn’t hear him through the sound of rushing wind that filled her head, maybe from the pounding of her heartbeat in her temples. She just lay there, staring, barely comprehending anything but the twinging aftershocks ricocheting around her system.
Then he was rolling her onto her back, and above her was the familiar sight of Diamond Tiara’s nethers – slightly bruised, far wetter and more aroused than she’d seen before, but unmistakably her lover’s lovely hindparts.
Then Diamond Tiara’s thighs were around her head, pressing into her ears, and her mouth was full of the pink pony’s tasty pink pussy.
Silver Spoon licked without thinking. She loved it when Diamond Tiara sat on her face, loved lapping at that luscious marehood until her tongue was sore.
But as she settled into her task, she felt a massive, insistent presence at her own unready pussy and she knew her tongue wouldn’t be the only thing that was sore.
She groaned into Diamond Tiara’s cunt as the human’s member plunged inside her. The two mares used toys only infrequently, so she wasn’t ready for the size, the hardness, the pummeling power of the human’s hard thrusts. It drove the breath from her lungs, drove her inching across the floor, drove her crazy with unstoppable pleasure.
As she surrendered to the feelings, she realized that she couldn’t breathe.
Diamond Tiara was rocking back and forth, sliding her wet pussy over Silver Spoon’s face, her tongue lolling out with lust so strong it was making her stupid. A particularly forceful grind forward left Silver Spoon’s nose free for an instant, and she sucked in as much mare-scented air as she could, but then the supply was once again cut off.
Silver Spoon’s eyes shuddered in their sockets, her lungs screaming at her, sudden panic competing with the unbelievable feeling of the human’s thumb circling her engorged clitoris while he fucked her with bestial abandon. She was slapping her forehooves at Diamond Tiara’s thighs, trying desperately to alert her lover of her plight, but Diamond Tiara’s head was thrown back, grunting with unladylike roughness as she came, grinding on Silver Spoon’s face and coating it with her juices.
The grey pony could feel her vision darkening as she asphyxiated, and panic shot up and down her spine. She had to get free, had to get air, surely Diamond Tiara could tell she was suffocating!
But no – all that Diamond Tiara seemed to be focused on was eking out another climax on Silver Spoon’s mouth and tongue. Silver Spoon wanted to bite her, but couldn’t make herself, and her hooves were getting so weak as she suffered and shook, dying for oxygen, for a respite from that hard-rutting human member, for relief from pain.
Her eyes focused on Diamond Tiara’s butt and tail as they moved back and forth, back and forth, like the human cock that was sawing her insides. The human’s hands gripped Diamond Tiara’s hips and shoved her down even harder on Silver Spoon’s face, and as Silver Spoon’s pussy clamped down on his dick with her death spasms, she felt his cum shooting into her womb, hot and wet, and her soul was plucked away on the wavering wings of her final climax.
Her hooves clattered against the floor as she relaxed in death, Diamond Tiara still riding her dead face.
The human gave her another few long strokes, as his balls shot more semen into her cooling body. Then he slapped Diamond Tiara in the face, making her jaws clack.
“Look what you’ve done,” he said, pushing the pink pony off her dead lover.
Diamond Tiara looked at Silver Spoon’s messed-up face, her open mouth, the smeared combination of human seed, mare juice, makeup and tears, the open, staring, horrified eyes, and gave a soft moan of sorrow.
“That’s a needy little pussy you have, isn’t it?” he said, but Diamond Tiara wasn’t listening. She crawled towards Silver Spoon, shaking with sobs, to kiss the cum off the grey pony’s face, already growing paler in death.
The human sighed and looked over at the princesses. They were still lost in their mutual masturbation, and he laughed at the expressions on their royal faces, then grabbed a royal guard’s spear from its place on the wall.
Diamond Tiara’s butt was in the air as she lavished belated affection on her murdered marefriend. The human gripped her by the tailed, raised it higher, and shoved the spear two feet deep in Diamond Tiara’s cunt in one thrust.
The pony gave an earsplitting shriek of pain, instantly transforming into writhing, thrashing motion, but he hoisted her fully off the ground by her tail and kept thrusting the spear downwards, piercing through meat and organs, punching through her diaphragm, just barely missing her heart.
Diamond Tiara was in so much pain that she couldn’t think of anything else, all other considerations distantly secondary to the pillar of agony punching further and further into her overstimulated body. It was the worst, most intense thing she had ever felt – worse even than the expression on Silver Spoon’s face watching Diamond Tiara cumming on a human dick.
She could feel its brutal progress, as it worked unstoppably through her body. It felt like she was being ripped in half. She could feel a retching horror in her throat, as the spear head kept slicing down, down.
Diamond Tiara wanted to beg for her life, but only blood dripped from her lips – blood and red bubbles of bloody saliva. Then as the human gave a rough grunt of effort, the red tip of the spear blade jutted out of her mouth.
Her eyes flared wide open at the horrible sight, and then she shuddered, coughed around the spear, and died choking on her own blood.
The human threw Diamond Tiara’s impaled body down on top of Silver Spoon.
“I’d like to keep these two around,” he said to the princesses after a moment. “Get the Resurrection Pool ready.”
Celestia drew herself to her feet, sighed contentedly, and smiled as she rang a bell. Her secretary, Raven Inkwell, poked her head into the room, suppressing a cry of distress at the wretched sight of Silver Spoon lying dead on the floor, Diamond Tiara thrown unceremoniously atop her, a cruel spear transfixing her from pussy to mouth.
“Call some guards to assist,” Celestia ordered. “We need to move these little ponies. Be quick now.”
Raven blanched and nodded, then turned to trot away.
The human looked down at the pretty, well-fucked bodies again. He looked forward to the two conflicted mare-loving ponies learning their new place in life – living and dying and getting fucked for his own pleasure.
“At least they’ll have each other,” he said contentedly. “They really are such a cute couple.”
Posted Jun 30, 2025, 11:28 PM UTC