r/solar•
MyRealUser

Help me compare solar quotes (north NJ) please! + Two concerns/questions about a quote from a popular solar installer

Solar Quote

Hi all,

I'm finally trying to jump on the solar train before the 30% credits expire at the end of the year. Comparing different quotes and reading a lot on this sub led me to a few reputable local companies to choose from, the leading one is a company which is somewhat local to my area (north NJ) and seems to have lots of good reviews and mentions on this sub.

But two things stand out when I compare their quote to others:

  1. They propose a larger system than most other companies. My roof angles are not optimal at all, and one section has a huge tree next to it. Other quotes have either avoided that section completely or minimized the number of panels in that section of the roof. This company covers this section with 7 panels. In terms of cost per Watt, they are cheaper than others, but with a larger system overall, the quote is more expensive. When I asked them about that, they said that "other companies are likely not accounting for shade", which I read as them trying to compensate for shade and sub-optimal roof angles with a larger system. I'm not necessarily against that, a larger system will allow room for more usage in the future (if I decide to get an EV for example), but it will set me back $6000 more. Does it make sense to install a bigger system and cover areas of the roof that may only get direct sunlight during the early morning?

  2. Some companies provide critter guards either as a standard or as an optional add-on. When I asked this company about critter guards, the sales rep responded with "Critter guards trap debris and limit production. These are not the exposed systems of 15 years ago." I have lots of squirrels and pigeons in my area and on my roof, and reading about critter guards in this sub (and other resources online), I feel like this statement is simply not true.

To compare my two leading quotes right now:

  1. 10.44 kW system that is expected to produce 11,800 kWh over a year, using 24 Q.TRON panels and Enphase IQ8HC-72 inverters, including critter guards, will cost me $29,000.
  2. 15.05 kW system that is expected to produce 12,420 kWh over a year, using 35 SEG-430 panels and IQ8MC-72-M-US inverters, and does not include critter guards (and advises against using them), will cost me $35,600

Any input is appreciated. I have another local company coming out on Monday for a site survey before they provide a quote, which I expect will be the most accurate since it's not just based on satellite images.

Posted Jul 4, 2025, 9:08 PM UTC

29

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 9 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.