Looking for an elegantly gooey barrier balm

I’m using Futurewise’s Slug Balm over tret. It’s a thick, clear, Aquaphor-but-maybe-slightly-more-elegant balm that locks in everything and makes me look like a dolphin when I wake up. I’m almost out and it’s discontinued and I’m heartbroken. What is similar? I know the Cerave ointment is, but I was hoping for something with a little…more? What about the Prequel Utility Balm? Is the Cicaplast more lotiony?