Best POD service for a small artist on Etsy?

I already sell giclee prints of my digital art and while I love my printer, they are primarily a photography printer and don't offer much in the way of anything outside prints, canvases, and photo albums. I'm looking for a POD that integrates with Etsy (and maybe Pic Time if that's possible), prints on things like totes, notebooks, stationery, mugs, etc, and is high quality. I've heard mixed reviews on Printify, and with Printful merging with them I'm nervous about them too. I'm based in the US and with the tariffs, I'd like production to stay here. I'm not looking for huge scale, I just can't keep inventory and ship myself anymore. A small business would also by a bonus, but I can't be too choosy in this economy. Any recommendations?