Tempted to switch from A1 to P1S with AMS 2. Looking for some advice.

I have the A1 with the AMS. It's great, but I have two limiting factors. First, the only place for it is in my room. I have fans and air purifiers running, but I don't want to run it at night due to the melting plastic. So I'm really limited to daytime runs only (Which limits my capacity severely). Also, my home is very humid. Like 56% in my room. I keep all my filaments in a humidity box, but once they're on the AMS there isn't a whole lot I can do. I do have a dryer, but it's only one roll.

I've been thinking about selling my A1 combo for the P1S since they're on sale. Is this a bad idea? I've heard the P1S is loud, could I sleep through it with white noise running? I mostly print PLA and PETG, can I run the P1S overnight with the door closed so it filters everything out or will PLA get too hot? Is the AMS 2 an adequate dryer? Am I overthinking this and should just stick with the A1?

Thanks!