Best game post Crystal Skull?

Hi y’all - SO excited to find this Reddit group! I played the first 17 PC games over and over again when I was a kid and have recently returned to this hobby in the past year or so. I can’t believe how many have been released since I stopped playing and have no clue why I ever stopped.

I’ve seen mixed reviews of many of the newer games but want to try one to see how the newer games stack up. What game would you recommend that I play that was released after CRY?

For what it’s worth, the games I loved the most that stick out the most in my memory are the ones that I felt were the most atmospheric and immersive. For me, those were CUR, MHM, TRT, DDI, and SHA. I’m not turned off by a game’s difficulty level and care much more about the general vibes and aesthetics as those are what drew me in in the first place.