White’s crashing when turning off bulbs

I’ve had about 10 white switches in my house for about a year now. They’ve been working well, maybe an occasional flutter or flash at the light bulbs.

I decided to convert from HomeKit to Home Assistant. I’ve been having issues with that (different problem), so I decided to just add them back to HomeKit and bridge to HA. Now after adding those switches to HomeKit, the first few switches I’ve added will crash whenever I turn the lights off (both physically or from the phone). The switches were factory reset multiple times, and it still happens on switches that have worked for months.

Any thoughts on why?

Appreciate the help