One choice I wish they would let the player make, instead of Arthur.

Just before the bank robbery in Saint Denis, both Dutch and Hosea try to convince Arthur to sway one way or another. Hosea wants to not rob the bank, and Dutch does. The game presents this as a dilemma. Do you choose Dutch or Hosea? But you never get a choice. The game chooses for you. I know this is because of the story, but they could have made a small fork here that later regions with the main story. That’s my only major complaint. Other than that, I love the game.