r/buildapc•
lite951

[Build Ready] PC damaged during shipping, working on a new one.

Old specs

PartDamage
Enermax Revolution 85+ 1050WSeems fine
Prolimatech MegahalemsBent quite a bit
EVGA X58 SLI ClassifiedMegahalems damaged the northbridge heatsink
Corsair Dominator-GT 3x2GB PC3-15000Seems fine
PowerColor Radeon HD 7870 LE (XT)Port-plate was bent, I unbent it and it seems fine
Cooler Master HAF 932Right feet dented-in, can't really stand, somebody dropped my baby
Intel Core i7 920Seems fine

This happened two weeks ago. I took it out of its box, laid it flat, unbent and popped the video card back in and booted it. It works fine, though the motherboard is reporting 120 degrees on the northbridge, and any bump of the case freezes the computer. Its been running ever since though. I even finished Dishonored on it.

I am thinking I will salvage some of the parts from this guy and make a new guy. With that in mind, here is my build

Part TypePartPriceReasoning
CPUIntel Core i5-4670K$230Absolute monster, I think this is a must
CPU CoolerProlimatech Megahalems Revision C$60Loved my old one, still have the two 12cm fans
MotherboardASUS Z87-PRO$200Great review from Anandtech
MemoryCorsair Dominator-GT 3x2GB PC3-15000re-usingStill works, timings seem ok? Not sure
StorageSamsung 840 EVO 250GB$182.99Great review from Anandtech
Video CardPowerColor Radeon HD 7870 MYST (Tahiti LE)re-usingDecent middle-of-the-road card (got it pre-760)
CaseNanoxia Deep Silence 1$133.58Great review from Anandtech, wanted a quiet case with dust-covers
Power SupplyEnermax Revolution 85+ 1050Wre-usingKicking strong, will work with z87?

What do you think?

I am most worried about the ram. Corsair Dominator-GT 3x2GB PC3-15000 was beastly when it came out (four years ago). Note the funky 3x2 configuration... It will have to run in single channel mode... Is this part going to be a bottleneck? What's the cheapest that I can best this ram for?

Thanks

Posted Sep 8, 2013, 4:15 AM UTC · edited

011
kmisterk•

Here is a super nice set that will give you dual channel with two gigs more at the same speed for relatively cheap.

Or you can use your current ram in asynchronous dual channel mode for no extra money.

Otherwise, your new build is definitely a solid one.

1
lite951OP•

So this was my question. That ram is 9-10-9-27 cas9. My ram is 7-8-7-20 cas7. Both are DDR3-1866. Isn't mine faster? I know very little about ram performance, but the numbers are certainly smaller...

1
[deleted]•

Yes, the C7 set is faster.

ASUS Z87-PRO is a premium class motherboard so you'd be paying for a lot of non-performance bells and whistles as well as integrated Wifi. I have the Z87-PRO and its a great motherboard (especially because I need Wifi), but the ASUS Z87-A is the budget optimal choice.

The seleted case is very expensive for the proposed build. Silence can be accomplished with a fan controller (present on both the Z87-PRO and Z87-A). My Fractal Arc Midi R2 is near inaudible because the fans throttled to 60%. Another method to accomplish silence without sacrificing airflow is to buy larger fans (less noise for the same amount of airflow due to throttling) or better fans. The Cooler Master R4 line of case fans are inexpensive, quiet at full speed and silent while throttled. There are better fans available, but high end fans cost quite a bit.

2
lite951OP•

Nuts. That ram is over four years old.

I didn't even know they had a cheaper z87 version that maintains most of the performance benefits, thanks.

How do I transform my build to be worthy of that case? Seems to me like I can only improve the ram and the videocard.

1
[deleted]•

Nuts. That ram is over four years old.

There's been a RAM shortage recently so prices have gone through the roof. 1866 Mhz C7 was likely "premium class" 4 years ago with a price tag to match.

How do I transform my build to be worthy of that case?

Its not a "worthiness" thing, its just that a "silent" system can be achieved with a cheaper case. A $140 case in a ~$1000 tower isn't budget optimal but if you really like the case, go for it.

2
kmisterk•

Yes, technically speaking it is faster, but the difference in most uses is negligible. Saving a few nanoseconds per instruction. At most.

1
[deleted]•

That's a pretty expensive motherboard.

1
lite951OP•

The new one or the old one? The old one was $584. I'm used to quality stuff, I don't want to cheap out.

1
[deleted]•

You're not getting better quality, just more expensive prices.

1
lite951OP•

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7c/Graham%27s_Hierarchy_of_Disagreement.svg.

Simply stating the opposite of what I stated is a pretty weak form of disagreeing. Please provide proof.

0
[deleted]•

I wasn't interested in making a long involved argument, but politely conversing with you and expressing my opinion.

This isn't a formal debate. I would actually say your argumentation is a pretty poor way to engage with me, it comes across as hostile and confrontational.

Next time try a less arrogant approach.

1