“You’re My Girl” from High Button Shoes - have you heard Harry sing it?

This is a longshot, but I thought I would ask. I’m 53 years old right now and back in my early 20s I went to a Harry Connick Jr. concert and during that concert he played a song that haunts me to this day (in the best way). I will never forget that song the rest of my life. It was the most beautiful and romantic song I think I’ve ever heard and the way he arranged it and sang it… Slow and subtle and sexy AF… I think about it even all of these 20+ years later. I have searched high and low across the Internet and music platforms to find a recording of him singing this song. It’s from the Broadway musical “High Button Shoes” and the title of the track is “You’re My Girl.”

I’ve listened to the original Broadway recording, and even some others who have covered this song. But nothing comes anywhere even close to how Harry sang it that night at the concert. I don’t remember what year or the location, because it was so long ago and I’ve gone to so many of his concerts over the years.

Anyone remember hearing that song? Anyone have a recording or know where to find one? Even just sharing this memory with someone who appreciated it as much as I did would bring my heart joy.

Posted Jul 14, 2025, 11:09 PM UTC

23
Loading comments…