r/Physics•
tsarus

Correlation does not imply causation, or under certain circumstances it does?

That correlation does not imply causation is one of the premises of science, and anybody who claims so looks like a fool. It is very usually seen for instance in the interpretation of scientific research on newspapers.

But does this have to do with the fact that the systems under study are very complex and not every variable can be assessed?

Consider a system with 1 degree of freedom, say the length of a simple pendulum. If I change the length and measure the period of oscillation, I will see a strong correlation between both, and we know for a fact that one does, in fact, cause the change of the other.

If we completely ignored the physics laws under which this occurs, we wouldn't be able to explain this, but given the degrees of freedom could we conclude that it's a cause.

How can we generalize this, that is to say, under what circumstances can we say that correlation does imply causation? When we control all the variables of the system?

Posted Sep 11, 2013, 2:09 AM UTC

85
Loading comments…