The Russells and the 400 List

SpoilerSeason 3 Discussion

I've done a deep dive into the 400 list to finally try to get to the bottom of how good a barometer it was for social position. We're not likely to follow these characters to 1892, when Ward McAllister supplies the New York Times with the supposedly official society list. The list is, of course, not an undisputed record of who was important in society. Older families were left off in favor of newer names, and there were no more than a few representatives listed for any family. The list experienced pushback in its day, and McAllister's standing had apparently already taken a knock by this point, thanks to his memoir. And yet the list continues to have almost mythic standing among anyone with even a passing knowledge of New York's social history. It wields authority to this day.

I think the list is something Bertha would have disliked being left off of. It would be interesting to see if McAllister would include her. But if she and George were included, she would be by far the most humbly born listee (I know there is discussion on this sub as to whether George's background is as hardscrabble as hers). There was virtually no one - if not no one - on the list who wasn't born to wealth. *Possible* (I'm unclear on their upbringings) exceptions to this were Heber Reginald Bishop and Henry Lawrence Burnett (both of whom had distinguished colonial ancestries and were well-connected in terms of their marriages) and Henry White Cannon (who had Mayflower ancestry). William K. and Alva Vanderbilt were not included, though three other Vanderbilts were. If their daughter had married the Duke by then, would they have made the list? I'm not sure. The family of the Duchess of Manchester wasn't included.

Agnes probably isn't socially active enough to make the list, and I imagine she would treat is as vulgar and beneath conempt ("As if I needed Ward McAllister and a newspaper to tell me who I am!"). But, still, it would be interesting to see the effect of the list's release on the world of The GA. Alas, we're probably not to see it.

Oh, and for anyone rooting for Aurora, the list included two divorced women and one separated woman.

Posted Jul 28, 2025, 10:23 PM UTC

93

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 3 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.