Besides the five of Tony, Parvati, Sandra, Rob, and Cirie, who else do you put in your Top 10 best players of time?

Interested to see what people have to say. Here’s mine:

6. SARAH LACINA Personality aside, you have to consider her accomplishments; an all-returnee win + lost at fire in all-winners. It’s interesting because her first season was her worst, which usually isn’t the case, but she has 3/3 merge and overall a strong voting record, especially in GC. Her biggest drawback is she’s never won individual immunity and people don’t love her personality/actions. Think her name deserves more respect

7. JEREMY COLLINS All-returnee winner and very strong performances in both original and all-winners. He gets voted out by two couples and the one guy whose couple Jeremy had just blindsided in SJDS, which is a way worse hand than most on this list. Cambodia he plays an amazing game and wins 10-0 with a correct idol play (which also gave him a pseudo-perfect game, again, with all-returnees), and made it to Episode 13 of WaW, surviving F9 and F8 with three votes against him, and losing to the King of Survivor. Very strong showings all around

8. MICHELE FITZGERALD 2/2 FTC with one being WaW is incredibly impressive, especially considering she played from the relative bottom the entire time on both seasons. Interestingly she got there in two different ways which I think makes it more impressive that she clawed her way to the end in both seasons. Has multiple clutch immunity wins, just no idols or idol plays.

9. JOHN COCHRAN I’ll start by saying Cochran’s Caramoan was a can of whoop-ass. In his first season, he makes Day 30 after being voted in 7/10 tribals and makes the season-defining move. In his second, he plays a perfect game against half-returnees with three individual immunity wins, orchestrating crucial F7 and F6 blindsides. I think people forget just how good his play was that season because we’ve agreed we don’t like it.

10. KIM SPRADLIN-WOLFE I admittedly think there’s a small drop off here, but Kim’s 1 season run in One World is almost enough to put in the Top 10. Completely dominated with 4 immunity wins and a 7 vote win. Comes back for WaW, wins an individual immunity, lasts til Day 29. Two very impressive showings, especially considered she was on the bottom/outs in the beginning of WaW.

HMs (In no order): Sophie Clarke, JT Thomas, Richard Hatch, Russell Hantz, Maryanne Oketch, Coach Wade, Yul Kwon, Tina Wesson

Can be added depending on their 50 performance: Ozzy Lusth, Colby Donaldson, Jenna Lewis, Rick Devens, Aubry Bracco, Dee Valladares, Kyle Fraser, Genevieve Mushaluk, Stephenie LaGrossa Kendrick

Can be added if they demolish 49 and 50: Rizo, Savannah