Favorite Female Challengers According to the Sub (2025 Edition)
So a couple weeks ago I posted this post asking members of this sub to rank their favorite men and women. This list is for the women, for the men go here. Without anything else to go over, here is the list:
25. Nurys Mateo (AYTO6) and Theresa Jones (Fresh Meat II)
24. Rachel Robinson (RR Campus Crawl)
23. Ruthie Alcade (RW Hawaii)
22. Tina Barta (RR South Pacific)
21. Da’Vonne Rogers (Big Brother 17)
20. Nany Gonzalez (RW Las Vegas 2)
19. Amber Borzotra (Big Brother 16)
17. Diem Brown (Fresh Meat) and Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: MvGX)
16. Melissa Reeves (Ex on the Beach 2)
15. Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat II)
14. Paula Meronek (RW Key West)
13. Emily Schromm (RW DC)
12. Jenna Compono (RW Ex-Plosion)
11. Amanda García (AYTO3)
9. Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea)
Debut: Challenge 2000
Latest Season: All Stars: Rivals
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #10
Peak: #9
9. Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor: Kaôh Rōng)
Debut: Spies, Lies & Allies
Latest Season: Battle of the Eras
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #12
Peak: #9
8. Katie Cooley (Road Rules: The Quest)
Debut: The Gauntlet
Latest Season: All Stars: Rivals
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #19
Peak: #8
7. Tori Deal (Are You the One? 5)
Debut: Dirty 30
Latest Season: Battle of the Eras
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #7
Peak: #5
5. Kam Williams (Are You the One? 4)
Debut: Vendettas
Latest Season: All Stars 4
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #8
Peak: #3
5. Coral Smith (Real World: Back to New York)
Debut: Battle of the Seasons
Latest Season: Gauntlet 3
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #6
Peak: #4
4. Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion)
Debut: Rivals 3
Latest Season: All Stars: Rivals
Upcoming Season: Vets & New Threats
Last Year’s Ranking: #5
Peak: #4
3. KellyAnne Judd (Real World: Sydney)
Debut: The Island
Latest Season: All Stars: Rivals
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #4
Peak: #3
2. Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat II)
Debut: Fresh Meat II
Latest Season: Battle of the Eras
Upcoming Season: Vets & New Threats
Last Year’s Ranking: #1
Peak: #1
1. Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat)
Debut: Fresh Meat
Latest Season: Rivals
Upcoming Season: N/A
Last Year’s Ranking: #2
Peak: #1
So those are the women. Sorry if you didn’t see the post and didn’t vote, there’s always next year. Leave your thoughts down below, any surprises? Or anyone higher or lower than expected?
Also go check out the men’s list and leave your thoughts there.
Posted Jul 29, 2025, 11:47 PM UTC