Why weren't the Mesoamericans better equipped to fight off European diseases if they lived in the jungle?

Wouldn't deadly diseases be a feature of everyday life when you are living in such a harsh environment? I can understand why groups who lived in more temperate regions were decimated, but I can't understand why the Aztecs and Maya didn't have immune systems at least as good as the colonizers'

Posted Sep 15, 2013, 7:53 PM UTC

67
400-RabbitsModerator | Pre-Columbian Mexico | Aztecs•

Because disease does not work like that and many Mesoamericans were not living "in the jungle."

To address the second part first, the Maya may have lived in in the jungle environments east of the Isthmus of the Tehuantepec, but the Aztecs and their associated Central Mexican brethren did not live in anything resembling a jungle. A great deal of Central Mexico has a temperate upland climate of which the only thing tropical is seasonal rains.

Now to handle the first part second, living in a humid and hot environment does not necessarily imply human disease. This association is popular in the Euro-American imagination because of the association with deadly human diseases in tropical parts of Africa and, to a lesser extent, South and Southeast Asia. Africa being the continent of our origin, however, means that diseases there had millennia to co-evolve with humans and spread with them to other parts of the Afro-Eurasian landmass. Infectious diseases are very picky organisms and require specific hosts and transmission vectors The greater biodiversity of tropical areas may mean there are greater opportunities for a zoonotic incident, but only if there are suitable hosts available.

A classic example of co-evolution of disease and the importance it has on transmission is Yellow Fever. The virus that causes YF is spread via the Aedes aegypti mosquito that feeds on primates, both human and non-human. Our evolutionary proximity to our hairier brethren means that particular insect vector does not discriminate, and thus happily serves as a bridge between jungle species and humans. This arrangement not only requires there to be a related group of jungle-dwelling creatures to serve as a wild reservoir for the disease, but also an insect vector that has co-evolved with both groups. This is something that literally had millions of years to develop over humanity/proto-humanity's history and then spread with us. Humans being such recent arrivals in the Americas, whose species and diseases had happily been evolving for millions of years without us, there were no such close relationships. Our most genetically related cousins in the Americas are the Platyrrhines (New World Monkeys) who are much more distant from us than Old World Monkeys and Apes. The only disease we've acquired from them that I can think of off the top of my head is Chagas. And again, much of Central Mexico is not the jungle environment they require; some species live along the Gulf Coast, but NWM ranges basically end at Tehuantepec or earlier.

Simply put, humans on the Afro-Eurasian landmass were living in a morass of bacteria, viruses, animal hosts, and vectors, which had grown up with, and adapted to exploit, humans. Humans in the Americas not only entered into an environment where they were foreign to the pathogens adapted to the creatures of that area. Those humans also missed the animal domestication events that introduced a host of new diseases into the human milieu, and their own animal domestication events ended up taking place thousands of years later. Even today, most of the diseases that plague the Americas today are imported from the "Old World," it's temperate and tropical areas alike.

8
Georgy_K_ZhukovModerator | Military Firearms | 20th Century Militaries•

I've recently encountered some discussion of this in a book I'm reading (A Social History of Dying), and as presented there, it is that animal domestication , or lack thereof, played a large part in the development of the immune system. In the Old World, there was a wide variety of domestication, and this cohabitation with animals meant that we developed a stronger immune system for being exposed to them.

In the Americas, where the only major domesticated animal was the dog, they lacked this same proximity to animals on a regular basis, and their immune systems didn't undergo the same continual assault that strengthened it over time. Once the Columbian exchange began, this meant that they were totally unprepared to deal with the diseases that came with the Europeans.

An example used in the book is tuberculosis, which has a bovine variety, and while epidemiology isn't my strong suit, I believe that smallpox vaccine was first surmised because of the closely related cowpox, with Jenner noticing that milkmaids were much less susceptible to the human variety, and figuring out it was because of their exposure to the bovine disease. The existence of these similar diseases in the livestock led to a more robust immune system in the eventuality of being infected with the more lethal human version of the disease, and a degree of cross-immunity that helped prevent disease outbreaks from being (generally) too devastating, while in the New World, lacking those interactions, such an outbreak could erase a significant portion of the population.

The exchange of disease wasn't totally one sided though, and one of the hypothesis concerning the origin of syphilis is that it was a New World disease that made its way to Europe following the arrival of Columbus, and although a somewhat accepted theory, the idea is still debated.

4
400-RabbitsModerator | Pre-Columbian Mexico | Aztecs•

A lot of this comment doesn't make much sense. There's no denying that animal domestication was the most important series of events that expanded the human disease pool, but I have a nit to pick with something in your second paragraph. I also find your third paragraph simply baffling, but more on that in a second.

In the Americas, where the only major domesticated animal was the dog

And the turkey, and the muscovy duck, and (in the Andes) the llama and alpaca. Not to mention the continuous interactions with hunted species like deer and tapir, or even the aquaculture of animals like turtles and various amphibians. That's the nit I needed to pick. The general point about less, and later, domestication of animals in the Americas stands.

What I cannot let stand is whatever point you are trying to make about smallpox and tuberculosis, or something. First, to sort this out: smallpox is caused by viruses (Variola major and minor), while tuberculosis is caused by a bacterium (Mycobacterium tuberculosis). Cowpox is caused by a different virus (Vaccinia), of which a closely related Vaccinia virus is used in the smallpox vaccination. The bovine form of TB is caused by a different bacterium (M. bovis) than the human strain, a fact that is further complicated by genetic evidence that suggests we may have given the disease to cattle, and not the other way around. The fact that TB was present in the Pre-Columbian Americas, but died out, further complicates things.

I think you're trying to make some point about the connected-ness of herd animals and zoonoses in that paragraph, but it is less than elegantly phrased and comes off more than a little garbled.

2
Georgy_K_ZhukovModerator | Military Firearms | 20th Century Militaries•

Fair enough!

In regards to the issue of domestication, I was merely taking the book at face value when it gave the dog as the only notable domestication. I'm kicking myself for forgetting about Llamas and Alpacas. What I was trying to get across with the issue of proximity was that mere interaction wasn't enough, but also living with the animals on a daily basis. Maybe I didn't word optimally, so here is the relevant passage:

The key difference between the Old World and the New World epidemiology is that the Old World cities and communities lived with domesticated animals in close proximity to humans (for example cows, chickens, horses). This encouraged and incubated a species transfer of disease agents. There was almost a complete absence of domesticated animals in the New World (except dogs) and this is the main reason why Old World diseases went rampant during Old World colonial expansion into the New (Social History of Dying 77).

As for the second contention, I think the issue you are having with it is a possible lack of clarity on my part. I didn't feel that I was stating bovine and human TB, or cowpox and smallpox were the same disease, but rather that they are closely related to enough of a degree that human interaction with the bovine strains was enough to assist in strengthening the human immune system for encounters with the human disease. To go to the book:

For example, the likely first tuberculosis bacillus to cause human disease was bovine in type. The increase in animal population density brought about by herding would favour a rise in bovine tuberculosis. We receive that bacillus through infected meat or milk. Both the tuberculosis and leprosy are derived from the same genus, with similar immune response and cross-immunity.

Or as I understand it to be implying, while in an Old World population, having been exposed to the related but less harmful disease, an outbreak of a disease that also has a bovine equivalent can be tempered to a degree by the cross-immunity gained from that interaction, while a New World population, lacking that earlier interaction to develop cross-immunity, would be simply devastated. In hindsight, I can see why my wording there would have come off as a bit sparse to get that across as well as possible. I'm going to go back and edit it slightly to clarify (Regardless, I think we can both agree your post is more eloquently stated, so if there is something here you feel is still just totally off the mark, I'll just go and delete it).

2
400-RabbitsModerator | Pre-Columbian Mexico | Aztecs•

Yeah, this was more quibble with the presentation that than the content. Particularly since the South American camelids were, um, confined to South America and that turkey domestication was not done until the late Preclassic/early Classic, the general idea about a lack of domesticated animals stands, even if I do have to sound all Jared Diamond-y in saying it.

For the latter part of the clarification, I wouldn't say that the relatedness of pathogens necessarily strengthens the immune system in regards to similar agents. Zoonotic events can and do have seriously virulent effects (just ask anyone infected with Herpes B), but a relatedness in genetics does imply a relatedness in pathogenesis. So you are basically right in that a long interaction with Mycobaterium spp. can select for resistances to the basic methods of infection and colonization of those individual species. Case in point, our descriptions of pre-Hispanic diseases in Mesoamerica are spotty, but there's some indication that illnesses like pneumonia and dysentery were present, yet this caused no massive counter-epidemic in the Europeans because the cause of these diseases predated Americans becoming separated from the rest of humanity. Humans had already been selected to have innate defenses against these sorts of infections. The rule of thumb in general is that longer associations with a host select for less virulent strains, although this is not always the case, particularly for rapidly mutating pathogens. On a side note, this is thought to have accounted for the rapid decline of virulence in syphilis in post-Contact Europe, though I've also seen suggestions that the rapid adaptation can be explained by syphilis being derived from less pathogenic trepenomal diseases that were already present in the Old World (if not necessarily endemic to Europe).

2
Georgy_K_ZhukovModerator | Military Firearms | 20th Century Militaries•

Also, a follow up question. You mention the evidence for TB in the Old World before the Columbian exchange, and I browsed through the link, but the answer to this didn't stick out. Do they think that the lack of immunity to the Old World strain of TB was due to the two having diverged to such a degree that immunity to one was not sufficient to give some level of immunity to the second? Or had the New World strain simply died out long ago enough ago that whatever cross-immunity might have existed at one point was no longer present by the time Europeans began to arrive with their strains of TB?

2
400-RabbitsModerator | Pre-Columbian Mexico | Aztecs•

The latter. TB managed to make it across the Siberian landbridge, but couldn't sustain itself in the Americas. The mobility and low density of early American groups may account for this, but the details of how outbreaks were managed in that particular chapter of history are closed to us.

In the comment I just made, I noted that TB is an oddball when talking about infectious diseases in no small part because of its long term association with humanity. As opposed to something like smallpox, it was a disease already endemic to human populations prior to the migration of Siberian peoples into the Americas. As such, the time period for the adaptation of the human immune system to the pathogen (and vice versa) had already occurred. TB is an example of an almost perfect human pathogen. It is ridiculously infectious, has a structure that stymies our adaptive immune response and antibiotics alike, can go into long latent periods before emerging, and takes it time killing its host. Since humans are (basically) the only reservoir for the disease, it has to be somewhat accomodating, unlike say Clostridium spp. which can hang out in the soil and then kill you in few days from gangrene or tetanus while not having anyway to spread from person to person.

2