TiakoTevinter apologist, shill for Big Lyrium•

Oh man, the good old "pictures of vaguely white looking Asians prove white people are indigenous to everywhere" argument. Love it.

Anybody from r/askhistorians would know about the Scythian empire stretching from Eastern Europe to Central Asia.

Nope. Not an empire.

None of them would be shocked or surprised by the concept of "Europe stretching out as far as Central Asia and Siberia," as I said.

It would just kill him to learn that Scythians are classified as Iranian.

Also,

Buddha in Northern India was most likely a Scyth

Let my skin and sinews and bones dry up, together with all the flesh and blood of my body! I welcome it! But I will not move from this spot until I have attained the supreme and final wisdom.

39
smileymanYou know who's buried in Grant's Tomb? Not the fraud Grant. •

Oh man, the good old "pictures of vaguely white looking Asians prove white people are indigenous to everywhere" argument.

To be fair, when I look at most East Asians I see people with white skin, so I would call them white. That does not mean I think they share a European culture or European ancestry or anything even remotely similar to that. Just that their skin color is white to me.

However, I feel confident in saying that's not what this particular user means when he says "white".

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
CroGamer002Pope Urban II is the Harbinger of your destruction!•

It would just kill him to learn that Scythians are classified as Iranian.

Make him learn, then.

1
Raven0520"Libertarian solutions to everyday problems."•

We may need to restrain him, something like this.

6
CroGamer002Pope Urban II is the Harbinger of your destruction!•

Perfect.

3
Grenshen4pxTruman = Worse than hitler because DAE hiroshima?•

Or this child from China: http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3265/2842452790_e08e4e5358.jpg

I like how he leaves it ambiguous so he knows idiots will think it means most of China.

The girl is an Uighur a mixed Turkic ethnicity in one of china's far regions.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/29126736@N08/2842452790/

This would be the equivalent of having a pic of a white south African with just the word "African" in the header.

35
DoctorDankMother Teresa was literally Hitler•

He was almost certainly, purposefully attempting to mislead people into into thinking she was Han Chinese.

28
whatwouldjeffdo5/11 Truther•

I'm no expert on China or India, but the word mongoloid stuck out. I didn't think even racists were using this word anymore.

22
PlowbeastNosy historians get the Sima Qian treatment.•

I believe it's Oriental menace or yellow horde now.

4
Georgy_K_ZhukovLend Lease? We don't need no stinking 'Lend Lease'!•

Hmm... I already had him tagged in RES as "Suck's hitler's dick".

On the plus side, that first pic, the "Hunza", is a real cutie.

21
_______QUEBEC_______Proud Member of the Liberal Brigade•

Suck is Hitler's dick indeed.

13
turtleeatingaldermanNobody had beef with Hitler. He was a vegetarian.•

I think the second picture is far more attractive.

3
Georgy_K_ZhukovLend Lease? We don't need no stinking 'Lend Lease'!•

Those baby blues...

3
ProbablyNotLyingI can mathematically prove that Hitler wasn't fascist•

Today I changed his tag from "secret neonazi" to just plain "nazi".

3
Raven0520"Libertarian solutions to everyday problems."•

Could you please explain why this is bad history?

17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

55
Raven0520"Libertarian solutions to everyday problems."•

And yet people are upvoting it and thanking him -_-

27
dr_root•

"Buddha was literally white and had blue eyes! Thx for blowing my mind man."

I never frequent r/todayilearned much but if his posts are a hit it can only mean the demographic is mainly high school kids..

22
Raven0520"Libertarian solutions to everyday problems."•

Nazis are good at blowing minds.

20
runedeadthAI'm a idealist. Like Hitler.•

When I first saw folks in r/whiterights using the word Negroid I laughed my ass off. Then cried a little.

16
[deleted]•

Can't remember where, but I've seen white supremacists use "humanoid". Like, not really human, but human-ish. Loooooooool.

6
TurnshroudFederation Justice Warrior•

Did they also say things like Homo sapien Mongoloid to distinguish their perceived subhuman groups like it was 1889?

4
buy_a_pork_bunFear my fleet of non-functioning Me-262s•

That whole subreddit makes me cry a little.

1
DrMikeTysonNeoReactionaries: the absolute quintessence of the badverse•

"Caucasoid territory". Up, that's the best lens to view the past: a big make showing what was/was-not Aryan land.

6
dashaaaOP•

"The white man was the original Chinese!"

29
partipo•

He just dropped this gold nugget:

Asians didn't even exist when the first Welshman set foot in what would later become London.

24
Grenshen4pxTruman = Worse than hitler because DAE hiroshima?•

if you check redditgraphs here's some of his frequent subreddits

http://redditgraphs.com/?drooperdoo&ScatterPlot&Length&Comments

libertarian

conspiracy

incest

22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

18
smileymanYou know who's buried in Grant's Tomb? Not the fraud Grant. •

The earliest humans in England date back 800,000 years. The earliest humans in China date back 1.6million years.

The famous Red Lady (who actually isn't female) is the oldest homo sapien remains found in Wales, and is 33,000 years old. The oldest homo sapien remains in China are 100,000 years old, and in fact are the oldest human remains outside of Africa.

8
imasadpotato•

I....i... I don't whether to cry or just punch some sense into his face. That is so stupid.

3
alynnidalarSanskrit helped the aliens build the pyramids.•

...correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't it pretty much universally accepted that people lived in Mesopotamia before they lived in Europe?

Or is the Middle East not part of Asia today.

e: I guess once I think about it, I actually have no idea where people lived first... but certainly there was civilization in Mesopotamia before Europe, right?

3
farquierFeminazi christians burned Assurbanipal's Library•

Anatomically modern humans lived in all those places well before words were put on clay, if that's what you are asking. If you are asking when civilization developed, then I suppose according to some definitions of civilization and some archaeologists, they did(although Egyptian civilization is contemporary or nearly so, IIR; Chinese I will have to look up when I get home and also see what Chinese archaeologists have to say about the emergence of social complexity in neolithic China), and Mesoamerican civilization was of course an entirely independent development. The problem is that civilization is a remarkably slippery term to define and one of the things people take as an indicator if it(writing) is notorious for not surviving well in archaeological contexts unless it's a monumental inscription. It makes more sense to look for specific things we can reliably predict surviving-monumental architecture in wood, earth, or stone, evidence of urbanization(for example, settlements of certain scale and density), evidence of social stratification(is there a noticeable difference in the size/orientation/layout of houses, in the number and quality of grave goods, or clearly walled-off or distinguished residential parts of the site?)

2
TheVoiceofTheDevilMoctezuma was literally Lincoln•

I... I don't really know what that could mean.

1
TiakoTevinter apologist, shill for Big Lyrium•

Basically, he doesn't understand the difference between indo-European, European, Caucasian, and the possessing some vague phenotypic similarity to modern Europeans. He also makes a huge deal of the Tarim mummies, which is kind of silly because we always knew the Tocharians were Indo-European. They were also far in the west of modern day China, nowhere near the traditional Central Plains cultural heartland.

23
DaeresBehold the Time-Travelling Killer Kushans•

Tocharians- in your Hellenistic Far East, absorbing your syncretic culture. Lock up your coinage standard, lock up your Greek alphabet.

15
ProbablyNotLyingI can mathematically prove that Hitler wasn't fascist•

I just wanted to let you know that I love you.

2
smileymanYou know who's buried in Grant's Tomb? Not the fraud Grant. •

I really don't want to go through all of it, but I'll do two paragraphs for you.

Indo-European tribes (who originated in Central Asia)

Sort of I guess, depending on what you define as Central Asia. The most commonly accepted hypothesis for where PIE originated is called the Kurgan hypothesis and says that the language originated with a group of peoples who lived in an area called the Pontic steppe. Problem is that area is huge--385,000 square miles huge.

That would be like saying that the Native American tribes originated in the plains of South Dakota.

The other issue I have with this part is the description of them as Indo-European tribes, when they're really not "tribes" as such, but rather share a common language.

had been going back and forth between Northern India and Eastern Europe for millennia.

Well no, not really. This is a huge simplification and generalization. Of course there had been contract via trade routes between India and Eastern Europe. However, to get to Eastern Europe from Northern India, you'd have to go through Pakistan, Afghanistan, Turkmenistan, Iran, Azerbaijan, and then you're in Georgia which is probably the closest place you could call Eastern Europe. Or you could go on the other side of the Caspian sea and go Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Kazahkstan, and then Georgia.

These Indo-Europeans spread Gothic places-names everywhere.

I think this user is confusing Gothic for Germanic. It's true that the Germanic languages are descended from PIE. However, saying that the Indo-Europeans spread Germanic place-names everywhere is like saying the Romans went and spread French place-names everywhere.

For instance, the very Germanic-sounding name "Goethe" [meaning "Goth"]

This is a completely made up etymology. [Goethe's](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goethe_(surname) name comes from an ancestor named Gottfried. The 'got' portion of the name means 'god' or 'holy', not Gothic.

Wikipedia has a pretty good write up of the etymology behind the Goths.

exists in Northern India as "Gupta"

No again. The Goths called themselves gutþiuda, which is probably where he's getting that from, but it's not related at all to Gupta.

13
ANewMachine615•

In my head, the Kurgan hypothesis has to do with a giant immortal warrior who will one day battle a Scotsman with a terrible accent for the ultimate prize.

5
idkydi•

THERE CAN BE ONLY ONE origin of Indo-European languages.

1
Arthenon•

Yeah, most people don't realize that Pakistan was born in London, on a city bus. There, an Indian intellectual (of Muslim extraction) thought of making up a pan-Muslim country in Central Asia. The "PAK" from his Pakistan was an acronym. "P," if I remember correctly, stood for Punjab, while the "A" was supposed to be "Afghanistan," and the "K" was Kashmir.

Going further down, this stuck out particularly to me. Pakistan literally means "Land of Cleanliness" or "Pure/White, etc" depending on translation. It's either Hindi or Urdu, not entirely sure. Definitely not some random person's idea on a London bus.

11
bracketlebracket•

Accoding to the infallible website Wikipedia, it's actually both.

It was coined in 1933 as Pakstan by Choudhary Rahmat Ali, a Pakistan Movement activist, who published it in his pamphlet Now or Never,[13] using it as an acronym ("thirty million Muslim brethren who live in PAKSTAN") referring to the names of the five northern regions of the British Raj: Punjab, North-West Frontier Province (Afghania Province), Kashmir, Sindh, and Baluchistan"

10
VortigernTarquinius Superbus was just as bad, you know•

As bad as his history is, it is a good collection of r/HumanPorn

10
vonstroheims_monocleEugen Weber Cooks- Noodle Peasants into Microwave Men•
9
Historyguy1Tesla is literally Jesus, who don't real.•

Surprised he didn't try to claim Genghis Khan as a white guy, too. I mean, he had red hair! Totally means he was Caucasian!

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
Historyguy1Tesla is literally Jesus, who don't real.•

Crap. Well, someone needs to tell him that plenty of Mongolian people have red hair without being white. Like this little girl.

14
thedboyHistory is written by Ra's al Ghul•

Stop it you people, I'm in here to laugh at racists, not be tricked into wanting to have kids.

11
Historyguy1Tesla is literally Jesus, who don't real.•

Cute little kids are the cure to racism.

11
ProbablyNotLyingI can mathematically prove that Hitler wasn't fascist•

They're only cute like that when they're still. They're only still like that in pictures. My wife and I are in hour #2 of the nightly bedtime battle. Learn from our example.

2