Should I buy a 2nd phone?

I accidentally had my s25 ultra and iphone 16 pro max fly out of my motorcycle jacket. I did receive replacements for both but they said its not refurbished but its a a new body with new parts. For iphone they said its brand new. It kills my ocd because now the original boxes dont match which hurts resale. Should I buy a 2nd iphone and s25 u? Or trade these in?