Source
r/PaulMcCartney•
RoastBeefDisease

Daily Song Discussion #364: We Three (My Echo, My Shadow, and Me)

Discussion

We Three (My Echo, My Shadow and Me)” is a 1939 song written by Nelson Cogane, Sammy Mysels and Dick Robertson. It was a hit song in 1940 for both The Ink Spots and Frank Sinatra with the Tommy Dorsey Orchestra.

Studio version

McCartney 1 7.20/10

  1. The Lovely Linda: 6.77/10

2.That Would Be Something: 8.21/10

  1. Valentine Day: 5.25/10

  2. Every Night: 9.48/10

  3. Hot as Sun/Glasses: 6.61/10

  4. Junk: 9.35/10

  5. Man We Was Lonely: 7.18/10

  6. Oo You: 7.22/10

  7. Momma Miss America: 5.71/10

  8. Teddy Boy: 6.53/10

  9. Singalong Junk: 7.16/10

  10. Maybe I'm Amazed: 9.63/10

  11. Kreen-Akrore: 4.53/10

Suicide: 5.48/10

Women Kind: 3.54/10

RAM 8.42/10

  1. Too Many People: 8.78/10

  2. 3 Legs: 7.20/10

  3. Ram On: 8.52/10

  4. Dear Boy: 8.79/10

  5. Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey; 9.32/10

  6. Smile Away: 7.70/10

  7. Heart Of The Country: 7.96/10

  8. Monkberry Moon Delight: 9.14/10

  9. Eat At Home: 7.89/10

  10. Long Haired Lady: 8.26/10

  11. Ram On reprise: 7.10/10

  12. Back Seat of My Car: 9.71/10

Another Day: 9.10/10

Oh Woman Oh Why: 7.95/10

WILD LIFE 6.68/10

  1. Mumbo: 6.08/10

  2. Bip Bop: 5.48/10

  3. Love Is Strange: 7.01/10

  4. Wild Life: 6.43/10

  5. Some People Never Know: 7.13/10

  6. I Am Your Singer: 6.30/10

  7. Tomorrow: 8.00/10

  8. Dear Friend: 7.04/10

  9. Give Ireland Back To The Irish: 5.74/10

Mary Had A Little Lamb: 6.50/10

When The Wind Is Blowing: 6.92/10

African Yeah Yeah: 2.56/10

Indeed I Do: 5.11/10

RED ROSE SPEEDWAY  7.87/10

  1. Big Barn Bed: 7.82/10

  2. My Love: 8.5/10

  3. Get On The Right Thing: 7.94/10

  4. One More Kiss: 7.59/10

  5. Little Lamb Dragonfly: 8.97/10

  6. Single Pigeon: 8.72/10

  7. When The Night: 7.56/10

  8. Loup (1st Indian On The Moon): 5.85/10

  9. Hold Me Tight/Lazy Dynamite/Hands Of Love/Power Cut: 7.88/10

Hi, Hi, Hi: 8.20/10

C Moon: 7.32/10

The Mess (Live At The Hague) 6.86/10

I Would Only Smile: 6.83/10

BAND ON THE RUN 8.72/10

  1. Band On The Run: 9.90/10

  2. Jet: 9.34/10

  3. Bluebird: 8.62/10

  4. Mrs. Vandebilt: 8.56/10

  5. Let Me Roll It: 8.89/10

  6. Mamunia: 8.18/10

  7. No Words: 8.05/10

  8. Picasso's Last Words (Drink To Me): 7.39/10

  9. Nineteen Hundred And Eighty Five: 9.56/10

Live And Let Die: 9.39/10

Helen Wheels 8.16/10

Country Dreamer 7.62/10

Junior’s Farm: 8.13/10

Sally G: 7.16/10

I Lie Around: 6.84/10

Venus and Mars 8.05/10

  1. Venus and Mars: 8.63/10

  2. Rock Show: 9.03/10

  3. Love In Song: 8.15/10

  4. You Gave Me The Answer: 7.69/10

  5. Magneto And Titanium Man: 8.85/10

  6. Letting Go: 8.71/10

  7. Venus and Mars (reprise): 8.43/10

  8. Spirits of Ancient Egypt: 6.49/10

  9. Medicine Jar: 8.10/10

  10. Call Me Back Again: 8.58/10

  11. Listen To What The Man Said: 9.33/10

  12. Treat Her Gently-Lonely Old People: 8.15/10

  13. Crossroads: 5.37/10

4th of July: 6.28/10

Walking In The Park With Eloise: 5.87/10

SPEED OF SOUND 7.08/10

  1. Let Em In: 7.84/10

  2. The Note You Never Wrote: 5.72/10

  3. She's My Baby: 7.06/10

  4. Beware My Love: 8.51/10

  5. Wino Junko: 6.12/10

  6. Silly Love Songs: 9.59/10

  7. Cook Of The House: 4.06/10

  8. Time To Hide: 7.33/10

  9. Must Do Something About It:6.88/10

  10. San Ferry Anne: 7.63/10

  11. Warm And Beautiful: 7.17/10

Mull Of Kintyre: 8.69/10

Girls School: 7.34/10

London Town 7.30/10

  1. London Town: 8.14/10

  2. Café On The Left Bank: 7.33/10

  3. Im Carrying: 8.12/10

  4. Backwards Traveller: 7.16/10

  5. Cuff Link: 6.62/10

  6. Children Children: 5.71/10

  7. Girlfriend: 6.38/10

  8. I've Had Enough: 6.88/10

  9. With a Little Luck 8.72/10

  10. Famous Groupies: 6.64/10

  11. Deliver Your Children: 7.89/10

  12. Name And Address: 6.32/10

  13. Don't Let It Bring You Down: 8.54/10

  14. Morse Moose And The Grey Goose: 7.76/10

Goodnight Tonight: 8.99/10

Daytime Nighttime Suffering: 9.22/10

BACK TO THE EGG 7.69/10

  1. Reception: 6.85/10

  2. Getting Closer: 9.39/10

  3. We're Open Tonight: 6.89/10

  4. Spin It On: 7.66/10

  5. Again And Again And Again: 7.28/10

  6. Old Siam, Sir: 8.45/10

  7. Arrow Through Me: 9.45/10

  8. Rockestra Theme; 7.00/10

  9. To You: 7.29/10

  10. After The Ball/Million Miles: 7.45/10

  11. Winter Rose/Love Awake: 7.90/10

  12. The Broadcast: 5.92/10

  13. So Glad To See You Here: 8.02/10

  14. Baby's Request: 8.15/10

Cage: 7.24/10

Robber's Ball: 6.82/10

Waterspout: 8.41

Did We Meet Somewhere Before?: 7.15/10

McCARTNEY II 7.23/10

  1. Coming Up: 9.22/10

  2. Temporary Secretary: 8.11/10

  3. On The Way: 7.45/10

  4. Waterfalls: 8.33/10

  5. Nobody Knows: 6.23/10

  6. Front Parlour: 6.06/10

  7. Summer's Day Song: 7.42/10

  8. Frozen Jap: 6.72/10

  9. Bogey Music: 5.04/10

  10. Darkroom: 6.71/10

  11. One Of These Days: 8.29/10

Blue Sway: 7.19/10

Check My Machine: 6.60/10

Secret Friend: 7.21/10

Mr. H Atom/You Know I'll Get You Baby: 4.22/10

All You Horse Riders/Blue Sway: 5.5/10

Wonderful Christmastime: 8.90/10

Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reggae: 3.06/10

TUG OF WAR 8.05/10

  1. Tug of War: 8.88/10

  2. Take It Away: 9.35/10

  3. Somebody Who Cares: 8.44/10

  4. What's That You're Doing?: 7.68/10

  5. Here Today: 9.29/10

  6. Ballroom Dancing: 8.58/10

  7. The Pound Is Sinking: 8.25/10

  8. Wanderlust: 9.19/10

  9. Get It: 6.61/10

  10. Be What You See: 5.90/10

  11. Dress Me Up As A Robber: 7.75/10

  12. Ebony and Ivory: 6.74/10

Rainclouds: 6.76/10

I'll Give You A Ring: 7.57/10

The Girl Is Mine: 6.72/10

PIPES OF PEACE 7.05/10

  1. Pipes Of Peace: 8.61/10

  2. Say Say Say: 8.72/10

  3. The Other Me: 6.89/10

  4. Keep Under Cover: 7.53/10

  5. So Bad: 8.09/10

  6. The Man: 6.43/10

  7. Sweetest Little Show: 6.75/10

  8. Average Person: 7.00/10

  9. Hey Hey: 5.31/10

  10. Tug of Peace: 4.02/10

  11. Through Our Love: 8.30/10

Ode To A Koala Bear: 7.94/10

Twice In A Lifetime: 6.97/10

Christian Bop: 4.95/10

GIVE MY REGARDS TO BROADSTREET 7.72/10

  1. No More Lonely Nights: 9.46/10

  2. Good Day Sunshine/Corridor Music: 6.57/10

  3. Yesterday: 8.31/10

  4. Here There and Everywhere: 7.72/10

  5. Wanderlust: 9.05/10

  6. Ballroom Dancing: 8.20/10

  7. Silly Love Songs/Silly Love Songs (reprise): 7.48/10

  8. Not Such A Bad Boy: 7.12/10

  9. So Bad: 8.52/10

  10. No Values: 6.91/10

  11. For No One: 9.06/10

  12. Eleanor Rigby/Eleanor's Dream: 6.70/10

  13. The Long And Winding Road: 7.28/10

  14. No More Lonely Nights (play out version): 6.87/10

  15. Goodnight Princess: 6.64/10

We All Stand Together: 8..17/10

Spies Like Us: 5.34/10

My Carnival: 6.60/10

PRESS TO PLAY 7.27/10 (7.44/10 w/ 13 songs)

  1. Stranglehold: 7.83/10

  2. Good Times Coming/Feel The Sun: 7.86/10

  3. Talk More Talk: 6.48/10

  4. Footprints: 8.64/10

  5. Only Love Remains: 8.06/10

  6. Press: 7.42/10

  7. Pretty Little Head: 7.98/10

  8. Move Over Busker: 6.52/10

  9. Angry: 5.25/10

  10. However Absurd: 6.68/10

Write Away: 8.29/10

It's Not True: 7.39/10

Tough On A Tightrope: 8.32/10

Снова в СССР 6.37/10

  1. Kansas City: 6.26/10

  2. Twenty Flight Rock: 6.38/10

  3. Lawdy Miss Clawdy: 5.68/10

  4. Bring It On Home To Me: 6.86/10

  5. Lucille: 6.70/10

  6. Don't Get Around Much Anymore: 7.14/10

  7. I'm Gonna Be A Wheel Someday: 6.01/10

  8. That's Alright Mama: 5.71/10

  9. Summertime: 7.18/10

  10. Ain't That A Shame: 7.52/10

  11. Crackin Up: 6.00/10

  12. Just Because: 5.13/10

  13. Midnight Special: 6.28/10

Once Upon A Long Time Ago: 8.90/10

Back On My Feet: 8.37/10

Yvonne: 8.14/10

FLOWERS IN THE DIRT: 7.73/10 (vinyl) 7.61/10 (CD)

  1. My Brave Face: 8.97/10

  2. Rough Ride: 6.83/10

  3. You Want Her Too: 7.47/10

  4. Distractions: 8.98/10

  5. We Got Married: 8.75/10

  6. Put It There: 8.76/10

  7. Figure Of Eight: 8.03/10

  8. This One: 8.71/10

  9. Don't Be Careless Love: 6.98/10

  10. That Day Is Done: 7.45/10

  11. How Many People: 6.49/10

  12. Motor Of Love: 5.39/10

  13. Ou Est Le Soleil: 6.20/10

Flying To My Home: 7.21/10

The First Stone: 6.78/10

Good Sign: 6.00/10

So Like Candy (1988 demo): 6.88/10

Playboy To A Man (1988 demo): 7.20/10

Party Party: 3.40/10

All My Trials: 6.66/10

OFF THE GROUND: 7.55/10

  1. Off The Ground: 8.09/10

  2. Looking For Changes: 6.05/10

  3. Hope of Deliverance: 8.75/10

  4. Mistress And Maid: 7.73/10

  5. I Owe It All To You: 7.17/10

  6. Biker Like An Icon: 6.80/10

  7. Peace In The Neighbourhood: 7.25/10

  8. Golden Earth Girl: 7.15/10

  9. The Lovers That Never Were: 8.80/10

  10. Get Out My Way: 6.37/10

  11. Winedark Open Sea: 8.08

  12. C'Mon People: 8.46/10

Big Boys Bickering: 6.72/10

Cosmically Conscious: 7.75/10

Keep Coming back to Love: 6.98/10

Sweet Sweet Memories: 6.52/10

I Can't Imagine: 7.49/10

Kicked Around No More: 8.26/10

Down To The River: 6.04/10

Long Leather Coat: 7.50/10

Style Style: 7.83/10

Deliverance: 5.23/10

FLAMING PIE: 7.96/10

  1. The Songs We Were Singing: 8.13/10

  2. The World Tonight: 8.68/10

  3. If You Wanna: 7.02/10

  4. Somedays: 9.21/10

  5. Young Boy: 8.35/10

  6. Calico Skies: 9.65/10

  7. Flaming Pie: 7.90/10

  8. Heaven On A Sunday: 7.91/10

  9. Used To Be Bad: 4.97/10

  10. Souvenir: 8.54/10

  11. Little Willow: 9.11/10

  12. Really Love You: 4.25/10

  13. Beautiful Night: 9.16/10

  14. Great Day: 8.68/10

Looking For You: 6.27/10

Broomstick: 6.36/10

Love Come Tumbling Down: 8.20/10

Same Love: 6.72/10

A Room With A View: 4.98/10

RUN DEVIL RUN: 7.42/10

  1. Bluejean Bop: 7.20/10

  2. She Said Yeah: 7.31/10

  3. All Shook Up: 8.27/10

  4. Run Devil Run: 7.99/10

  5. No Other Baby: 8.96/10

  6. Lonesome Town: 7.82/10

  7. Try Not To Cry: 6.68/10

  8. Movie Magg: 7.50/10

  9. Brown Eyed Handsome Man: 8.02/10

  10. What It Is: 7.85/10

  11. Coquette: 7.06/10

  12. I Got Stung: 6.35/10

  13. Honey Hush: 7.21/10

  14. Shake A Hand: 6.19/10

  15. Party: 7.02/10

Fabulous: 7.55/10

Maybe Baby: 6.80/10

DRIVING RAIN: 6.58/10

  1. Lonely Road: 7.29/10

  2. From A Lover To A Friend: 6.75/10

  3. She's Given Up Talking: 7.11/10

  4. Driving Rain: 6.41/10

  5. I Do: 6.77/10

  6. Tiny Bubble: 6.60/10

  7. Magic: 7.18/10

  8. Your Way: 7.06/10

  9. Spinning On An Axis: 5.45/10

  10. About You: 6.80/10

  11. Heather: 8.59/10

  12. Back In The Sunshine Again: 4.33/10

  13. Your Loving Flame: 7.50/10

  14. Riding To Jaipur: 6.15/10

  15. Rinse The Raindrops: 6.89/10

  16. Freedom - Studio Mix: 4.47

Vanilla Sky: 7.10/10

I'm Partial To Your Abracadabra: 6.72/10

CHAOS AND CREATION IN THE BACKYARD: 8.46/10 (8.54 without track 14)

  1. Fine Line: 8.95/10

  2. How Kind Of You: 8.97/10

  3. Jenny Wren: 9.33/10

  4. At The Mercy: 8.13/10

  5. Friends To Go: 8.87/10

  6. English Tea: 8.24/10

  7. Too Much Rain: 8.94/10

  8. A Certain Softness: 7.73/10

  9. Riding To Vanity Fair: 8.80/10

  10. Follow Me: 7.71/10

  11. Promise To You Girl: 8.21/10

  12. This Never Happened Before: 8.65/10

  13. Anyway: 8.52/10

  14. I've Only Got Two Hands: 7.42/10

Growing Up Falling Down: 7.58/10

She Is So Beautiful: 7.31/10

Comfort Of Love: 8.23/10

Summer of '59: 7.50/10

I Want You To Fly: 7.43/10

This Loving Game: 7.23/10

MEMORY ALMOST FULL: 7.87/

  1. Dance Tonight: 7.79/10:

  2. Ever Present Past: 8.70/10

  3. See Your Sunshine: 7.79/10

  4. Only Mama Knows: 8.58/10

  5. You Tell Me: 7.81/10

  6. Mr. Bellamy: 9.04/10

  7. Gratitude: 6.03/10

  8. Vintage Clothes: 8.12/10

  9. That Was Me: 8.10/10

  10. Feet In The Clouds: 7.30/10

  11. House Of Wax: 9.03/10

  12. The End Of The End: 8.87/10

  13. Nod Your Head: 5.23/10

In Private: 7.30/10

Why So Blue: 8.39/10

222: 8.62/10

I Want To Walk You Home: 6.95/10

KISSES ON THE BOTTOM:

  1. I'm Gonna Sit Right Down and Write Myself a Letter: 7.22/10

  2. Home (When Shadows Fall): 6.35/10

  3. It's Only A Paper Moon: 7.34/10

  4. More I Cannot Wish You: 5.95/10

  5. The Glory Of Love; 6.18/10

Posted Aug 7, 2025, 12:59 AM UTC

1311
Loading comments…