Arch for beginners

After missing quite a few Jupiter Broadcasting episodes I have recently watched the first episode of Chris' Arch challenge.

Ever since I found out about Arch I've wanted to give it a go, but every time I've tried it, I ran into some sort of problem that I just cannot get over. Now I'm fairly confidant with Linux since I've been using it for a couple of years, but I'm not that great at trouble-shooting problems simply because I usually configure my system once and then just let it be.

I would like to give Arch another go, but in my experience the Arch comunity, much like the Debian comunity, is not very newby-friendly. I understand people giving you the RTFM-answer, but sometimes the FM is just not that easy to understand.

One of the reasons I want to use Arch is because it forces you to trouble-shoot and solve the problems that arise, so I would appreciate someone to help me through the debugging process, rather than asking for a log-dump and telling me what command to type to fix the issue.

So, is there any other beginners to take up the Arch challenge, and is there any more experienced guys willing to help us out when we get stuck?

Posted Sep 17, 2013, 9:18 AM UTC

1241
Lorizean•

I don't consider myself a Linux expert or anything, but I've been running Arch for two years or so now and I'd be glad to help.

About the Arch community: I've always found the beginners IRC channel to be very helpful, the forums not necessarily as much.

3
AM255OP•

Oh, wow! Less than 15 minutes and two people allready offer their help, I'm quite impressed.

Thanks for the offers guys, I'm definitely taking up the Arch challenge then. :D

3
uoou•

*celebrates with a nice cup of tea*

5
thawkth•

Good luck! I'm also trying this in the next few days :)

I tried in Virtualbox on my win8 box the other day, and I could never get it to boot. I did follow the beginner's guide in the wiki.

I'm going to try a bare metal install now on a fresh drive :)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
uoou•

I'm not sure how experienced I'd describe myself as but I use Arch and I'd be glad to help. I know there are a few other Arch users as well and I'm sure they'll all help too.

2
blackout24•

I find the people on the Arch forums to be very patient and helpful actually. There is even newbie section.

I'll offer my help, too. You'll be surprised how trivial your roadblocks that you run into are. There's nothing hard about Arch at all. It's just that you don't know better, yet.

2
mostlybob•

The main difficulty I had with Arch was getting the joystick going. I may have given up too soon, but the wiki page was daunting enough for me to say to heck with it.

1
angryRake•

The forums yes - IRC - hit or miss.

0
prennis•

asking for a log-dump and telling me what command to type to fix the issue.

Asking you to post logs is the first step in helping you through the debugging process.

How far were you able to get with Arch?

I don't think many beginners fully appreciate that nearly all of the issues encountered by Arch newbies already been covered extensively on the Arch forums. With the exception of a month on Ubuntu, Arch was my first Linux distro. In the 8 months I spent with Arch, I never found it necessary to ask for help on a forum, not because I was a Linux expert, but because answers to my questions were already available, either on the wiki or the forums. My point here is that if you are an Arch beginner, you can save yourself and others a lot of work by searching for answers to your questions instead of asking them on a forum.

2
AM255OP•

Fair enough, but when you do not know what to look for in log files, they are very daunting and not all that useful. So I would much rather have someone take me through the process in such a way that I can troubleshoot it on my own next time around, or even help the next person that struggles with it.

The furthest I have gotten with Arch yet was completing the install process, but the machine wouldn't boot after that, so I must not have followed the instructions as closely as I thaught.

But that was then, this time I will make it work. :)

2
angryRake•

IMO logs should be at the ready, on pastebin, when you ask for help.

0
ub1quit33•

I'm a veteran Archer who was but a wee Linux beginner when he started his arch journey, so I feel your pain. I learned many tough lessons on the road to archdom, but every last one of them worth it, and I'll gladly help out at any turn so maybe you don't have to bump over the same rocks ;)

2
nighterrr•

Count me in as well, we could make a board for us! Although I don't have internet nor a computer for the next few weeks, I'm also an arch begginer and would like to participate in the community (really using linux for a bit over a year and a half, not count the ubuntu shenanigans, and just installed Arch on bare metal machine, which sadly I won't have that much access to anymore)

2
ProfessorKaos64For Science!•

You can message me anytime for help. I am also typically on IRC, ProfessorKaos64 on freenode, and on www.thelinuxcauldron.com. I like being helpful so don't ever hesitate to ask. I went through just what you did in 2004, and a little in 09 when I went back to Arch, and now on it full time. Good luck!

Tip when following the beginner guide: you'll see some commands ask to make 'systemctl' changes while you are in 'chroot' "mode". You cannot do this in chroot, so be sure to do them once you are fully logged in. At least this was this way the last time I checked the guide a while back.

2
jonjonr•

I'll be following this .... Arch challenge is on my short list.

1
astroboy589•

Install it in Virtualbox or Vmware Workstation if you can to learn how to install it and do it 3 or 4 times from scratch.

1
the-moose-machine•

I decided to make it extremely difficult for myself and jumped directly into Arch with XMonad. In my experience I have met some really helpful people along with some others being rude for the sake of it. However as far as Arch itself is concerned, I certainly learnt a hell of a lot about Linux in this process and Arch is now my distro of choice. Go for it, bro, and take that plunge. You can always fall back on Mint if things don't work out.

1
AM255OP•

It's funny you should mention Mint, that's actually my distro of choice at the moment.

1
UnderwaterCowboy•

I've found that outside of forums (hell, probably more than a few IN forums), Arch users are super willing to help out a noob.

1
AM255OP•

You mean like the LAS Reddit? ;)

2
UnderwaterCowboy•

HELLYEAH! You guys are okay, no matter what anyone else is saying. I know y'all never did most of .... er.... some of that stuff.

1
super_nathan•

Find a zenmaster, and have them help you install. If you are near Asheville, NC I'd be glad to help.

1
thawkth•

zenmaster?

I'm not familiar with the term :)

1
AM255OP•

That might be a problem. I don't live in the USA and I don't really know that many Linux experts and non that know Arch.

1
super_nathan•

Arch is just one of those things. The only way to learn it and to get "good" at it is by doing it. A mentor can speed the process up, but at the end of the day:

success = (lots of time+(many mistakes/fixing breakage))
1
angryRake•

dmesg is your friend.

Also install and configure syslog.

Daemons and applications usually have a verbose mode to run on the shell.

strace is great to debug a binary that isn't acting right and you cannot obtain information through logs. Example: missing files, libraries etc.

strace [binary] 2>&1 | grep -i [expression]

Don't forget the 2>&1 or you cannot "grep" it

This is how you output it to a file:

strace [binary] 2> file.txt

The Arch wiki literally tells your everything you need to know to walk you through an installation for the first time. Your graphics and sound are two annoying issues you may or may not run into - so be aware.

IRC has some complete dicks - get use to it. Don't be nasty in return or no one will help you.

I'll help where I can. I just subscribed to r/archlinux and added you as a friend.

Arch is nice but just expect things to go wrong from time to time. This usually happens after an upgrade and the arch home page usually has a fix - ALWAYS CHECK THE ARCH HOMEPAGE FIRST!

Other than that - don't expect everyone on the internet to be friendly. There are plenty in the Arch community that are friendly. Personally, I found the Gentoo community much more friendly.

1
ctx77•

Why should he install redundant software(syslog)?

1
angryRake•

Easier to control logs - preference I guess.

0
spyingwind•

I got stuck at installing grub. First with a GPT disk, then an MBR disk. Both failed to boot. Loaded up Fedora 19. Haven't looked back.

I really wanted to try. Arch, but the documentation for setting up your boot loader felt incomplete or lacking clarity.

1
nighterrr•

Funny, because I installed it not a full month ago and the bootloader section of begginer's section was pretty clear. Again, it might have been that I was using BIOS, not UEFI boot.

1
blackout24•

Simply don't use GRUB it's the worst piece of sh*t software I have ever seen. All people want to do is to load a kernel. GRUB somehow manages to split this up into 15 commands (just type grub and auto complete from there and see how many grub commands there are). You can't even use a simple config file to reference your kernel image and initramfs. You have to edits some 2000 lines long config templates and gerenerate the final config with grub-mkconfig. I'm using Syslinux for year now and never looked back. The most KISS bootloader there is. Works with everything.

-1
crshbndct•
pacman -S grub
grub-install /dev/sdX
grub-mkconfig -o /boot/grub/grub.cfg

Its really not hard at all.

2
blackout24•

Not hard at all until you want to change some of your default kernel parameters and you have to fiddle with files in /etc/grub.d/. Good luck finding, where your actual kernel line starts in that mess... I hate GRUB. All you actually need in a bootloader config file is two lines.

LINUX ../vmlinuz-linux root=/dev/sda1quiet rw
INITRD ../initramfs-linux-ck.img

GRUB 2 somehow thinks you need 300 lines for this and you can't edit it yourself you need a special command to genereate your config from seven 300 lines bash templates. Just look at /etc/grub.d/10-linux!! It makes you throw up.

2
denisfalqueto•

Agree completely. When grub 1 was deprecated, I've moved to syslinux and never looked back.

1
spyingwind•

At first grub-mkconfig failed to create those lines.

Then the second try at installing on an MBR partition, it failed to install the second stage.

I installed Ubuntu, it was... painful to use, so I installed Fedora. I am mostly a Debian guy, but wanted to try Fedora once again. I remember the SUSE days of using yum. It feels almost as if I'm in the right place, almost.

1
ctx77•

You will have a hard time with any software if you don't read the documentation....

Also you are supposed to make such configurations in /etc/default/grub ...

the rest is regenerated for you by grub-mkconfig.. with the help of the HELPER scripts in /etc/grub.d .. which you don't need to look at, even with complicated LVM crypto setups..

You might as-well proclaim that firefox is shit because "/usr/bin/firefox" looks ugly in a text editor.

1
ProfessorKaos64For Science!•

Never had a problem with grub. The OPs issue above mainly points to GPT etc. GPT is tricky if a new person does not know to make the small partition prefix for BIOS boards (like I did at first), or where to install grub to* when using such a setup. Grub.d is not hard to understand at all. They have all the documents online to explain all of this. I do agree Syslinux is easier, but I guess I like the hard way haha.

1
AM255OP•

Thanks guys, I really appreciate your willingness to help. I'm definitely going to take you up on your offers. :D

I grabbed the Arch torrent last night. I might not get time this weekend since I'm going to the MTG pre-release and I still want to read through the installation instructions before attempting them. But if I don't get to it this weekend, then definitely the following weekend.

I have an old Dell notebook at home that I'm going to use, but I want to make sure that I don't overwrite the hidden partition with the Windows installer on it. If this goes well, I might want to put Arch on my main PC, and then I will need my notebook for my Windows stuff.

1
beyere5398•

Maybe try Manjaro? It's based on Arch, can access the AUR and installs lickety split. I've been using it for a couple of months and have been pretty happy. The forums are also more newbie friendly. EB

-2
blackout24•

I would not recommend Manjaro to complete Arch beginners. You'll still have to use pacdiff every once in a while if you don't want to run into problems at some point. If you never used proper Arch you'll never learn how to use and maintain anything that is based on it. If you use a spinoff that comes with some AUR wrapper preinstalled, you'll never learn how to really use the AUR. This will again lead to inevitable problems at some point. I remeber countless threads even on the Arch forums, when the qt package was renamed to qt4 which caused AUR packages to break which left people unable to use makepkg helpless. This pretty much sums it up: http://jasonwryan.com/blog/2013/04/09/helpers/ In general if you're unable to set something up you are unable to maintain it.

5
ProfessorKaos64For Science!•

I second blackouts answer. Manjaro is not something I would suggest to someone wanting to learn Arch either. It goes the same for GUI programs for sysadmins. Sure, they are great, but you damn well know what that tool is doing underneath, and most do, or they woulnd't have a job :)

1