What is the human instinct that instantly senses when something is “off” — and could AI ever have it?

I was watching a movie about humans and AI, and it made me think about this instinct we have — that split-second ability to sense when something feels “off.” I started wondering if that instinct is truly unique to humans, or if it’s just our own kind of programming. Here’s the train of thought I had while reflecting on it:

With regards to the AI stuff, watching the movie I’m thinking of the human instinct where we have “logic” of senses rules criteria etc and in a seconds notice we can instinctively notice if something is odd and clock it and shoot it down (pointing it out as the AI). What is that instinct? Who wrote that code? Who knows. That’s the beautiful magic and excitement of being human. We can instantly tell from our code what is not logical and mark that as AI. Setting ourselves apart. Because we are authentic? But really it doesn’t mean which one human or AI is the “real”. Because we each have our frame of reference (as in quantum mechanics) that real and logic are based on our own bases / wiring. Thats the terrifying part of being a human. Why are we constantly scanning and evaluating if it is real or human or AI or not? Ironically, we do so in a way that is so mechanical. I’m starting to think that humans and AI are just two different bases / frames. We are constantly scanning for “real or fake”. The instinct we have inside to know if it is human or not. What is that? That’s the code or logic speaking. Instincts of things we see like Elvis or sentimental music or poetry or art etc that instantly triggers that human emotion. That’s our logic, that’s our code. That’s the most probable reaction to that act / stimulus we perceived. All we do is calculate the most probable next action. This movie is pure genius dude. Team human and team ai. We are two version of the same things from different bases in the set. We keep trying constantly scan and prove which is the real one. Destined to fight each other (as in the movie). Why?