turnover rates and USG%

naturally, a player that has the ball in his hands and does a lot of ball handling is going to turn it over more times per game/minute than the average role player and look worse in that particular area on the stat sheet

people cite usage percentage (usg%) to provide concrete evidence for this idea when comparing players

if you look at the formula for usg% though:

100 * ((FGA + 0.44 * FTA + TOV) * (Tm MP / 5)) / (MP * (Tm FGA + 0.44 * Tm FTA + Tm TOV))

a player's turnovers are already included in usage percentages. if player A and player B shoot the same number of shots, but player A turns it over more, player A will have a higher usg%

i bring this up because higher USG% is OFTEN used as an excuse for the high turnover rate, but thats not really a very valid explanation when you consider a turnover itself will inflate usg%. it seems to me that its the high turnover rate that inflates usage% ineffectively, not the other way around

Posted Sep 18, 2013, 10:30 PM UTC

717
LieutenantKumar[NOP] Anthony Davis•

Thanks for the informative post. But I think its a chicken and egg type scenario. While its true that turnovers themselves lead to an inflated usage rate, its also true that minutes played is a factor used in calculating the rate. There for it seems somewhat natural that the higher minutes a player plays, the more turnovers he is likely to get due to various reasons including fatigue. So it feeds back into itself. Idk, I could be wrong here.

4
pulling_stringsOP[LAC] Chris Paul•

right, i think there are a lot of things to look at. one for example, a player's assists arent included in usage or turnover percentages, but more passing will inevitably lead to more turnovers. magic has a 20% usg% and a 20% tov%, but you can't just ignore a 3:1 ast:tov ratio and a 45% ast% either.

im just trying to point out the difference between how much a player touches the ball, how much he's being used by an offense, and the usg% statistic specifically

3
sodapopSMASH[GSW] Harrison Barnes•

It's almost as if you need a USG% w/o turnovers and a separate TOV% based on 100 plays, or something like that, to compare how many possessions per 100 are being turned over.

It's also an interesting point that assists aren't factored, although of course they couldn't be, because someone else who makes the hoop will be the one getting usage off that possession - can't have two players getting that!

I dunno, maybe I'm not making much sense, haha.

1
swollencornholio[GSW] Stephen Curry•

There is a TOV% actually.

But there does need to be a usage stat that somehow incorporates assists in order for it to make sense to me. Otherwise pass first type players are always going to have a lower usage value compared to shot first type players.

1
sodapopSMASH[GSW] Harrison Barnes•

Ohhhh right I think I messed up, I think I meant one consistent with usage - one is per time on the floor, the other is per 100 plays. Ast% is also time on the floor. Wouldn't it be more useful to have them all the same?

I am not a statistician so would appreciate someone explaining to me why it's done that way... heh

1
tkfuRaptors•

It actually is a valid argument if you're talking about turnover rate (i.e. turnovers per 36 minutes, or per 100 team possessions, or whatever). Why? Let's imagine two players who play the same amount of minutes on the same team (so the denominator of the USG formula is the same), and who have the exact same proportion of FGA, FTA, and TOV. The difference between them is that player A takes 20 FGAs, 8 FTAs, and commits 4 TOs per 36, while player B takes 10 FGAs, 4 FTAs, and commits 2 TOs per 36.

They're both turning the ball over on the same percentage of the possessions that they use, but player A's turnover rate is twice as high, because his usage is twice as high. If each of them committed one extra turnover per 36, Player A's usage would rise by 3.6%, while Player B's usage will rise by 7.3%. That is to say, an extra turnover has less marginal impact on a high-usage player's usage rate than a low usage player's.

But the good news is, there's a much better way of measuring turnovers than raw rate numbers.

There is a stat called TO% (you can find it under the advanced stats heading at basketball-reference.com) that tells you what percentage of the possessions a player uses end in turnovers; in this example Player A and Player B would have identical TO%. For that reason, I find it to be a much more useful stat than simple turnover rate.

2
pulling_stringsOP[LAC] Chris Paul•

Thanks for doing the math on that, the thought had crossed my mind, but I got a little lazy about it.

And I agree tov% makes a lot more sense and is a lot simpler, but I don't see people use it as much

1
[deleted]•

it seems to me that its the high turnover rate that inflates usage% ineffectively, not the other way around

I wonder if anyone's done a hard look at this.

Personally, when I say high-usage players turn the ball over more frequently, I'm not specifically referring to the stat.

1
pulling_stringsOP[LAC] Chris Paul•

not specifically referring to the stat

and thats how it should be. to me, the list of high usage players should include guys like marc gasol and joakim noah, who are responsible for a lot of very difficult interior passes that don't necessarily lead to something in their own stat line unless they turn the ball over in the process.

itd be nice if the league could start giving us hockey assists now that SportVU has been installed everywhere...

1
LieutenantKumar[NOP] Anthony Davis•

Looks like Hollinger actually accounts for assists in his calculation:

Usage Rate = {[FGA + (FT Att. x 0.44) + (Ast x 0.33) + TO] x 40 x League Pace} divided by (Minutes x Team Pace)

1
swollencornholio[GSW] Stephen Curry•

Is your shift key missing?

0
pulling_stringsOP[LAC] Chris Paul•

Nope

1