Life p3 replacement, P30i vs p2 mini vs liberty 4 anc?

My right Life p3 stopped charging so im looking to replace my earbuds, from what I read, on sound and comfort the closest earbuds are the p2 mini. They are also the cheapest, but lack noice cancelling and other features. I dont know if the mics work as well as my p3s.

The p30i is not that far in price, and come with most of the p3 features but are not that great on sound or comfort and based on video review, the mics kind of suck.

Right now the p40i is not available no idea if the are good or not.

The libertys 4 anc are on discount, less of what I paid for the p3s but more way more the p2 minis. Ive seen mixed reviews on these earbuds and every aspect.

Ive seen the New p41i, but they are expensive and the highlight of those is not sound but battery life.

What should I Get?