Another Psyche thread
I wrote a comment about this in u/NeoNelito's "git gud" thread, which never responded to, and my thoughts have evolved a little since, but I think it's worth trying to narrow down what problems people are having with the new Psyche system, as opposed to the general "feels bad" that seems fairly common.
I think the Situational Morale and Sanity are fine, they are essentially what we had in the previous patch, minus resting which gets it's own 15%.
My issues are with Diet Morale (DM) and Lifestyle Sanity (LS).
After reflection, DM is just... Hunger 2.0.
My initial issues with it were that it felt so wasteful to eat food when I was at 0% or 2% hunger just because DM was low, and further, it doesn't seem possible to eat food not wastefully, given that most dishes give 1-6% DM, but will give 10-40% hunger, and you lose that morale quicker than you gain that hunger, at least in my experience.
Once I got over the feeling of it being a waste, and just started eating like a pig (I just bought/made and ate salads at every opportunity), DM issues stopped, but it still feels... off, that you have to gorge yourself constantly to maintain DM, even if you're not hungry.
My problems with LS on the other hand...
Based on VVayfinder's comment here, it seems like you gain 3% a day from each of asking for rumours, completing a level-appropriate contract, and praying.
Early on, I wasn't having too many issues with LS, I was asking completing contracts regularly, as you do early and mid game, asking for rumours frequently because I wanted to find and try out the new caves, and praying occasionally (I always rush the dwarf runestone) after I got back from being messed up in a dungeon.
However, after Rotten Willow, I began running into issues.
I'm playing Hilda, and after getting to the Rotten Willow and doing contracts there, I decided to spend some time exploring, looking for caves, and also hunting for my Bone Charm bonuses.
LS took a plunge because:
-
There's no contracts for caves and general exploration.
-
There's no one to ask for rumours when you're out and about exploring.
-
The dwarf prayer buff does not expire, and playing Arcanistics I was able to stay relatively safe and never fell below the 30% hp threshold that would have removed it.
This feels like an oversight, this system seems to directly punish exploring the world, which doesn't seem like what the devs would want?
The dwarf prayer buff especially seems like something that wasn't considered, am I really supposed to be locked out of getting prayer LS just because I *haven't* risked death?
The LS tooltip does say you get some from cooking and crafting, but I was doing both of those, and if I was getting any, it was negligible enough that it can't offset the general decay.
The result is that I'm usually in the range of ~60% Sanity, and undead or vampire dungeons will get my Situation Sanity down to below 50.
This doesn't feel good, I'm being punished for just... exploring.
These changes have generally felt like a miss, DM just being Hunger but with a new coat of paint, whilst LS favouring contract spam, it just doesn't feel like it makes much sense.
Posted Aug 19, 2025, 10:15 AM UTC