TIL the Blob movie is based on a police report from 4 Philadelphia police officers who witnessed a glittering, glowing, humming , purple glob that had fallen from the sky. It tried to climb a phone pole but evaporated when they touched it.
mysteriousuniverse.org/2011/07/beware-the-glob/Posted Sep 28, 2013, 5:07 AM UTC
Charles Fort had a term I love. People like himself were called skeptics [i.e., they questioned things]. People who always stuck to the humdrum explanation were NOT actually skeptics (because, at bottom, they were always champions for the establishment view). He called them conventionalists.
People like Michael Shermer and the Amazing Randi are actually conventionalists.
They believe that all phenomena can be explained by things in our current sphere of knowledge.
There is not one establishmentarian position that they've ever questioned or disagreed with.
Charles Fort was brilliant at showing you how tortured (and unrealistic) the explanations of the conventionalists can sometimes be. (Check out his book "Lo!" to see a massive list of examples.) Fort didn't use this example, but it kind of fits in with his observations: A psychic named Leslie Flint appeared to be able to produce voices from about a foot away from his body. People during sittings were freaked out by how clear and distinct they were. Flint was challenged to produce the voices in laboratory conditions, with his mouth covered by several layers of tape and plaster, and a microphone set up by his lips (to catch any acts of ventriloquism). Flint consented. The conventionalists set the conditions: He went to their lab; he allowed them to set up their controls; he was hooked up to their equipment. Yet the voices still appeared, crisp and clear. No muffle whatsoever. And once again, they seemed to appear about a foot away from his body, and about two feet up toward the ceiling.
The conventionalists were stumped. How the hell could the voices still be coming through crisply and clearly, when the guy had five layers of tape and plaster over his mouth? Why wasn't the microphone by his mouth picking up any signs of primitive ventriloquism?
It didn't fit in with their expectations (or their worldview). Flustered, one of the conventionalists said, "He must have learned to speak through his bellybutton!"
I'm not making that up.
Charles Fort was awesome at showing you case after case after case, where people claimed to have debunked things, and he shows you how in reality they debunked nothing. And that their own tortured explanations were even more far-fetched and comical than those advanced by the supernaturalists.
He loved the "They all must have had a mass-hallucination" excuse, when multiple eye-witnesses saw the same thing.
It's an easy out. But it's not scientific. People having hallucinations don't share them. No two lunatics ever see exactly the same vision.
Yet they'll peddle that explanation as if it's the obvious [albeit un-scientific] catch-all explanation.
In reality, "mass hallucinations" rarely if ever happen. (But they won't tell you that.) Charles Fort, however, will. He'll go into the literature and show you how exceedingly rare it is. Yet to the conventionalists, it happens all the time. (Because it's an easy scammy way to explain away stuff that baffles and stumps them.)
It's the go-to "He-was-talking-through-his-bellybutton" excuse.
Those "explanations" that are more scientifically farfetched than the simple observation that "weird stuff occasionally happens."
My take on the policeman and the blob? It's weird that no one on this thread holds out the possibility that exotic forms of matter exist. (They'll believe it if they read about it in a Physics journal.) But to actually see an example of it----
Suddenly, that's not to be brooked.
What if the blob was real? And that the cops didn't have the convenient (statistically improbable) mass-hallucination? And what if there was no proof later on, because--as an exotic form of energy--it wasn't going to register on the primitive tools available at the time-period?
Hell, the Higgs boson didn't register on equipment from the time. Yet it's real.
There are literally tens of thousands of things that we now know are real, that they didn't back in 1958. So it seems kind of myopic and self-serving to say, "Hey, if it couldn't be proven with 1958 technology, case closed: totally not real!"
I mean think about it this way: Imagine having a black piece of paper. And imagine you having a flashlight. You click on the flashlight for five seconds and train it on the black piece of paper. Then you turn the flashlight off. Would instruments brought to the scene five hours later ever be able to prove that the paper had had a circle of light on it for five seconds?
Of course not.
So if you can't even prove that, how the hell are you supposed to be able to prove that exotic matter briefly entered our dimension and then faded back into its own?
The problem is that you can't use lack of evidence as a proof for evidence of something else. You can hypothesize what it might be but until you prove that it is something you can only say you don't know what it is.
For instance with the psychic voices the person came up with a hypothesis that it was ventriloquism and tested that hypothesis. At the end of the experiment they found no evidence of ventriloquism as Flint's throat produced no noises. The problem appears when the skeptics mentioned consider this to be proof that his claims are valid, that he is in fact capable of producing sounds psychically, when all that has truly been proven is that his claims are not invalid, which is entirely different.
Now the bellybutton hypothesis is quite silly but is also completely testable. They could lower the microphone and repeat the experiment and if nothing happens then that hypothesis is also rejected, but still you are only proving his claims are not invalid, not that he is psychic.
It's certainly true that there are things in this world that we don't, and perhaps won't ever understand, but that doesn't mean that the first semi-reasonable explanation is real because we can't figure it out. With the blob I could certainly speculate that it could be energy from another dimension or an alien species but all I can really say for sure is "I don't know, but I would like to find out".
No, I totally agree with you 100%.
I, too, am for testing things with every possible tool we have available. But, that being said, I intellectually know that it's feeble caveman logic to think that the boundaries of the universe coincide with our primitive tools.
As I said regarding the Higgs boson particle, none of the tools they had previously were calibrated delicately enough to register the changes necessary to observe it. But now we HAVE certain tools [at the CERN institute] that can faintly pick up the data. Or take dark matter as another example. 97% of the universe is supposed to be made up of "dark matter," yet it eluded notice for 99.9999% of human history because our instruments were not subtle enough to detect it.
In other words, sometimes it's the saner position to say: "Maybe our technology has not caught up with certain phenomena".
So I'm not asserting that "Everything that people claim to see MUST be real," simply that, in certain cases, it's wise to withhold judgment.
And what I particularly don't like about the conventionalists is their assertion that we have all the tools to measure everything; and if these tools can't pick it up, the people who claim to have witnessed something are all liars. Or worse: idiots.
I saw a case of this recently. A conventionalist was trying to debunk CCTV footage of teaboxes which seemingly levitated off the shelves in a supermarket. There were two of these small cardboard boxes. And each seemed to slide from their niches on the shelf until they got into the middle of the air. Then they dropped. The conventionalist who claimed to debunk it said, "Ah, I can prove it's fake! How? I can recreate it by stringing fishing wire across the aisle and then tugging along the teaboxes so that it looks from a distance as if they were levitating."
That's an excellent START to debunking. (Because it sets up a plausible alternate theory.) But it falls short of ACTUALLY debunking it by leaving out certain facts. For instance, the shelves did not have hollowed out backs, from which someone could be on the other side, manipulated objects remotely. They proved it by showing you the shelves, whose backs were solid metal walls. In other words, you couldn't be on aisle 3, manipulating objects on the shelf in aisle 4. The shelves themselves precluded that.
So for the conventionalist's alternate prankster theory to work, you're not supposed to know that.
You're supposed to think that someone an aisle away was pulling string through the solid metal wall of the shelf.
Is it possible, then, that he drilled holes?
Excellent! Show me the drilled holes.
The conventionalist did no such thing.
He also failed to show footage of the alleged hoaxsters setting up the fishing wire. In addition, he failed to show later customers walking through the aisle and getting caught up on the fishing wire.
You'd have to do BOTH of these things to ACTUALLY debunk it. You can't just say, "Hey, I can recreate it on my hollow shelves at home, therefore it's fake!"
By that logic, because player-pianos exist, concert-level pianists have been proven not to be real.
"Hey, I can recreate it, therefore it's fake!"
You can recreate ANYTHING.
The fact that you can doesn't mean that the real thing doesn't exist.
So many conventionalists rely on this half-assed logic.
"I debunked it, I debunked it!"
No, actually you merely only offered a counter-theory. (And for that counter-theory to hold water, it has to align with the facts as we know them.)
Because in the case of the teaboxes and the supermarket, I would love to see the full, uncut surveillance footage. And I will be the happiest man around if we can bust the pranksters setting up the elaborate hoax. But if you don't have footage of them setting it up, and you don't have people walking through the aisle later and encountering fishing wire, then your "debunking" is extremely problematic.
It's simply not enough to say, "I can reproduce it by some other means." (Or, rather, I can reproduce it on my hollow-backed shelves at home, and not on the shelves as they actually existed in the supermarket.)
It's that kind of intellectual laziness that I despise.
It verges on dishonesty.
If he were really intent on solving the problem, he would have demanded to see the full, uncut raw feed of the store's video surveillance.
But he did not such thing.
What he did was offer an alternate theory (and one that didn't even match up with the facts as they existed in the supermarket), and he hoped you didn't notice.
A good read. I like the "conventionalist" tag. I am myself a skeptic, but would draw the line at explanations that beggar imagination.
The voice/bellybutton thing reminded me of the "magic bullet" think in the JFK assassination. How far will you go to make evidence fit a preconceived notion, rather than again applying Occam's Razor and conceding a second gun may have been used?
The "space jelly" thing may not really be that far-fetched, it's been postulated for years the building blocks of life may have come from space. I have also read many reports of comets appearing to contain organic-type compounds (which are not necessarily organic in origin.)
TIL -indeed - "the blob" was based on a news account.
It also rather reminds me of "Invasion of the Body Snatchers." I did like the original, but the 1970s remake with Sutherland, Goldblum et al is far and away the best version. Great cinematography, lighting, editing and direction, and the effects are great. Actually goes to show that digital isn't always better.
You do realize that Occam's Razor is not an objective truth and is really just an empty maxim for logical problems. There are Anti-Razors used by some of the most highly regarded philosophers most notably "If three things are not enough to verify an affirmative proposition about things, a fourth must be added, and so on."
I wish I could give you more than one upvote.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leslie_Flint#Fraud
It was proven that he was bullshitting.
That's true. But people share the same memory of a vision ALL THE TIME. Just give them half an hour to talk among each other before you ask them to put it down in writing.
This. Just give people a moment to reorganize their memories and suddenly they will all be the same. And then of course there are those instances of group/mass hysteria such as all of those Christian TV scam artists that knock down entire crowds of people and/or give them seizures using their god-power. Groups of people can be strong sources of proof but they have just as much capacity, depending on the circumstance, to be completely inaccurate/insane.
That's a complete misrepresentation; a blatant straw-man.
They are not scientists or researchers. Very few non-scientists are inclined, much less sufficiently informed or equipped, to challenge the accepted scientific consensus on any issue.
That sounds like a joke to me. Perhaps you are looking too hard for fault here to see clearly?
It doesn't matter. A "what if" could be posited for literally anything. What if every fictional story ever conceived were literally true in an alternate universe? So what?
People who investigate "strange phenomena" see fraud and delusion constantly. Not surprisingly, they tend to assume that it is by far the most likely explanation for every strange thing they hear claimed. These people would not, however, agree that a phenomena such as "exotic matter" could not possibly exist, only that there is insufficient reason to believe that it exists. Of course, you're not even defining what it is you're claiming, so how can it even be denied?
Without evidence, there is absolutely no reason to take any such claim seriously. Such a claim, can have no effect on anything. It cannot advance science, and it cannot provide any useful information to anyone about anything. So a story like that is just a story, and whether it's fiction or non-fiction is actually irrelevant.
It's entirely possible that it could be proved, depending on the light source, the paper, etc.. Your point that not all phenomena leave evidence is a non sequitur though. There is presently no evidence for Halley's Comet, it cannot be seen or produced on command, yet it is accepted as a real thing. Nobody has ever actually observed a quark or a Higgs boson or a black hole.
If something only ever happened once, would it be taken seriously by anyone? No. How would you distinguish such an occurrence from delusion or deception? You cannot.
Let's grant that, of the millions of reports of strange phenomena, some small fraction of them are completely real. Which ones do you take seriously? They all have the same level of evidence: none. Is it really enough that four people have the same story?
Now let's assume we appoint you, or Mr. Fort, to declare to us which phenomena are really exotic reality, and which are delusion or deception, and you declare this "blob" story to be a 100% genuine apparition of exotic matter. Then what? What possible effect is there on anything?
[deleted]
Skeptics don't give explanations. They require them. The only reason you think they give explanations is because non-skeptics operate by claiming that there is no scientific explanation, therefore this or that non-falsifiable explanation must be the correct one. Since that is unscientific, a skeptic will point that out and that for it to be considered there must be a falsifiable explanation, and they will often give an example.
For example, the obvious explanation or this is that it was a mass of animals, probably insects, swarming or mating or massing for some other reason.
Your post demonstrates a great deal of misunderstanding about scientific method and science in general.
Science doesn't prove things. That is a huge part of your misunderstanding. It merely doesn't accept cockamamie explanations that provide no actionable results when there is no falsifiable explanation and/or there is a more plausible falsifiable explanation. That is why things like this are generally rejected.
No, skeptics ask questions.
Conventionalists are the ones who want to shut questioning down. ("We already have all the answers.")
You claim that my statements prove a misunderstanding of science. I would say that your statements prove that you have a grave misunderstanding of what skepticism is.
You seem to think that skepticism = clinging to establishment opinions, and attacking anyone who questions an orthodoxy.
True skeptics question everyone: the weak and the powerful alike.
The mark of the fake skeptic is that they just question the weak. (The powerful, establishmentarian view is always unassailably correct, according to them.)
And that's where they lose credibility.
I would love just once to see The Amazing Randi or Michael Shermer question an establishment position, and to REALLY look into it. But they don't.
They just attack the people questioning.
They're the biggest gate-keepers for orthodoxy.
And that's my problem with them. As someone once said [correctly] of religion: "Why look for answers? We already have the answers. They're right here in the Bible. No need to question things if you already have all the answers."
And that's my problem with conventionalists. They think they already have all the answers. Our current scientific knowledge is supposed to be capable of answering all questions . . . because, after all, there's nothing new to discover. Right?
So if in 1958, they couldn't prove that the Higgs boson effect was real, then by golly it must be a lie.
If in 1958, they had no idea that "dark matter" was 97% of the universe, then it must be rambling by idiots.
The truth is: We learn how much we DON'T know every decade.
Conventionalists make no allowance for that. Like the religious people they claim to be superior to, they assert that they already have all the answers.
It's like the old axiom: "To the man with a hammer every problem is a nail."
Likewise with conventionalists like the Amazing Randi, "To every question I don't understand, there must be stage magician sleight-of-hand and trickery."
Everything for him comes down to that. That's his specialty, and by golly nothing else exists outside his specialty. Like the man with the hammer.
Everything is nails. And it's just that simple.
But the reality is: It's not.
More exists in the universe than nails. More reality exists outside our narrow bandwidth of senses. The people who actually MAKE the discoveries are the people who don't claim "But we know everything already!"
Which is precisely why the Amazing Randi has zero Nobel prizes, or zero scientific discoveries to his name. None of the conventionalists do. Which is why they're this incestuous, creepy little cult, peddling their books to 16 year-old Redditors, and going on the entertainment circuit. They're underachievers. Failures. Myopic dogmatists whose mental rigidity precludes an original thought ever entering their heads.
Like I said, you don't understand how science works. That is why you think this about skeptics.
No, I like skeptics.
I despise conventionalists.
Stop calling conventionalists skeptics. They're nothing of the sort.
They're skeptical of nothing that they've ever been told by an authority figure.
You know who's a skeptic? Einstein.
He challenged authority figures like Newton.
The Amazing Randi has never seen a state-funded assertion that he didn't believe. Michael Shermer has never watched a TV clip from NBC news that he didn't credulously gulp up.
These men question literally nothing.
They're not skeptics. In fact, they're quite the opposite. (They invariably champion orthodoxies and attack only those who question orthodoxies. 100 years ago these would have been the men attacking Einstein for daring to put forth "conspiracy theories" that questioned Newton.)
And as for them understanding science--- My kid's 3rd grade Science textbook describes science as amassing data over long periods of time and analyzing it to see trend lines. That's what Duke University did over a series of decades, analyzing paranormal claims.
Duke University actually used the scientific method.
The Amazing Randi?
His gimmick is: "I'll study one person for a whole hour. And if in that hour, they can't satisfy my own arbitrary, made-up-ass criteria, then the paranormal doesn't exist."
That's fine for Randi's contest. But that's not actually the scientific method.
The scientific method requires that you study hundreds (if not thousands of people) and that you amass massive amounts of data, and THEN you compare it to statistical measures from control groups to see trend lines.
Randi doesn't do that.
Studying one person for a whole hour isn't science.
(Using Randi's version of "science" we can prove that cigarettes don't cause cancer. "Hey, I studied Fred for a whole hour and he didn't develop cancer in that time-period. Therefore cancer from cigarettes is debunked!"
Maybe I should send Randi my kid's 3rd grade text book. (He'd benefit from it greatly.)
I lost faith in the high school dropout who calls himself "The Amazing Randi" when he got busted propositioning underaged boys for sex. (See: February 11, 1996 Toronto Star article on Randi's involvement in the Eldon Byrd case.) He then joined the board of a pedophile front group called "The False Memory Foundation". They routinely go to trials to defend people accused of pedophilia, whereby they try to convince the jurors that the children are just "imagining it". (In fact, one of the directors of the False Memory Foundation was arrested for kiddie porn. Two others gave interviews to pro-child pornography magazines. One such magazine was called Paidika. You can Google articles on Paidika and the False Memory Foundation's Ralph Underwager (who was later arrested).)
These are Randi's friends; these are Randi's colleagues; these are the people who share Randi's longtime passion for defending pedophiles from the criminal justice system.
This is the reason Randi came out as "gay" a few years back. His critics were about to leak recorded phone-calls of him propositioning underaged boys. To head off the scandal, he claimed he was gay and that his enemies were just out to "get him". He thought that by branding himself as "gay" [instead of as a pedophile] he could neutralize the worst of the disclosures.
Echoes of James Randi came up recently with another member of this group: Richard Dawkins. He made the news for defending pedophilia. "It never hurt me," he said, after describing how a male teacher felt him (and other students) up when he was young. Here's an article on it: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/09/12/atheist-richard-dawkins-doubles-down-on-mild-pedophilia-claims-amid-furor/
That's why I called this group of conventionalists a "creepy little cult". Their members make any decent person's skin crawl.
These are your heroes?
Ok. This appears to be a long line of things I disagree with. I would like to describe it differently, but I'll be nice and civil.
Could you give a source on the bellybutton story? I cannot find any info on Leslie Flint beyond some tests involving tape over his mouth when he did his seances in his own home, in the dark, where the tape was found to be moved afterward, and where Flint refused further testing.
I see this a tad too much. There's an odd view of scientists in general that a lot of the ideas they think of are less or guessed- that they are of equal merit to your roommate's idea that the pudding keeps being eaten by a robber, when his girlfriend's lips are oddly choclately. When you read those ideas in a physics journal, you're reading about an idea that has reasoning and evidence behind it- Exotic matter isn't something those guys came up with for no good reason, it was made because it had a good probability to be the right answer based on the data. Sure, there might have been a strange new form of matter that happened to come down in front of these two officers- Or maybe it was just something else. You cannot assume it's just "exotic matter" because of a few fallible eyewitness reports- The reason skeptics generally stick with conventional explanations is because the conventional explanation is the most common one, because that's the most likely explanation.
One of the scientists who studied Flint was a Dr. Louis Young. You can hear Flint mention him in this lecture (around the 12:00 minute part: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ydumO2iULQ)
You can find other scientists, too, who studied him if you do some more research. But that's the main thing: research.
The problem with "casual research" of paranormal subjects is that most people go to Wikipedia. There are so-called "skeptic brigades" whose stated goal is to alter stories to reflect their world-view. So they'll doctor pages, remove information, and even invent false facts to give the impression that 1) No legitimate studies have ever been undertaken, and 2) All cases were simple cases of stage magician tricks.
Recently, Neil deGrasse Tyson has complained about these skeptic brigades for altering his own Wikipedia page (changing him from an "Agnostic" to an "Atheist".) He's tried to change it back 16 times, but they keep altering it (to give the impression that "he's one of them".) Here's a thread covering the topic: http://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/1l2faq/til_neil_degrasse_tyson_tried_updating_wikipedia/
As for the "skeptic brigades" themselves, here's an article on them and their tactics: http://subversivethinking.blogspot.com/2013/10/wikipedia-rupert-sheldrake-susan-gerbic.html
Long story, short: I know that any quickie Wikipedia search of Leslie Flint that you'll find will be slanted, doctored and filled with misinformation. By design. You're supposed to come away saying, "Oh, he's been debunked? It was just that simple? Of course!"
When the reality is: He was never debunked.
But you're not supposed to know that.
Also like you're not supposed to know that self-proclaimed master-debunker Harry Houdini was himself caught cheating. He couldn't expose any fraud when he was analyzing psychic Mina Crandon. So he instructed his assistant to put a retractable metal implement by her, so that he could later pretend to "discover" it and claim that he caught her cheating. Embarrassingly, the man was busted planting the device. He would later sign an affidavit admitting Houdini's ruse.
But the guerilla skeptics will never let you know of this case.
Though the affidavit still exists and is easy to find.
Nevertheless, they go around, lionizing him as a "master debunker" and a "champion for honesty" when in fact he was a bigger con-man than the people he was pretending to debunk.
As for Leslie Flint? Go read his book "Voices in the Dark". He gives the names, dates and citations for the scientists who studied him. Fact-check those sources. See if they check out.
I did it years ago. (Since I don't have a copy of the book and can't recall the names and dates, I have to ask you to conduct your own research.)
But that's the thing: Conduct your own research.
Don't assume that Wikipedia is some fount of honest of objective information. Neil deGrasse Tyson, for one, knows it's not.
Could you give some sources for your story on Houdini?
Also, there's the fact that your man Flint's various "ghosts" all happened to have an English accent. Even Gandhi, who sounds a lot different in his speech here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yMcNubXqc4
Than in his seance by Flint: http://www.leslieflint.com/audio/gandhi.htm
So either Gandhi spent his afterlife in ghostly London, or he's getting more than a little help from Flint.
Yeah, all of Flint's "ghosts" have his same vocal inflections. His explanation (take it or leave it) is that the entities are using his vocal cords.
What's interesting on these recordings is that you can occasionally hear Flint laugh or cough while the voices are still talking. People who attended these sessions were freaked out by how Flint would be across the room, sleeping--audibly snoring--while the voices went right on, crystal clear, with no indication whatsoever that "clever ventriloquism" was in play. You can hear Ursula Reeg, for instance, talk about being present at some of these sessions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCdj6o2UXSY
Anyone who's ever actually seen a professional ventriloquist can see right away that they're very obvious when you're two feet away from them. (It's an art that only works when you're extremely far away in a concert hall.) Up close, even the best ventriloquists look incompetent. You can clearly see their mouths moving, their lips trembling and their throats pulsing.
With Flint, no.
People were right up on top of him. No telltale lip-moving. No muted consonant-switches in the projected voices (as you can see with ventriloquists), no muffled change in tenor (such as when a ventriloquist drinks from a glass of water as he's still talking). Flint's voices were pristine: clear and unmuffled. Seemingly having the ability to rattle on and on, even as he was documented laughing or snoring. You can hear him in the recordings.
As for myself . . . ?
I don't necessarily believe in spirits (though Flint clearly does). There were fascinating studies done by a woman named Leonora Piper, where her "control" was a spirit named Dr. Phinuit (who claimed to be a dead French physician). No evidence could ever be turned up to verify that such a physician lived at all in France, or anywhere else. In the end--though the phenomena was real--the interpretation may be wrong. The possibility exists that some of these "personalities" are akin to those of people suffering from multiple personality disorder. The "psychic," tramautized by coming into contact with The Source, creates a fake personality to stand in between as an intermediary. Much like an abused child will create a phony personality to shield themselves.
I hold to the Alexandra David-Neel's "tulpa" hypothesis . . . that human beings can manifest some crazy stuff, energies drawn from their subconscious. And not knowing what to make of it, they externalize it and say, "Ah, it was a spirit". Or "It was a ghost".
In reality, it might be far simpler: What the Egyptians called one's "higher self". (That's what Carl Jung believed.)
Who knows what the most accurate interpretation of the phenomena is. But some really good tests have been done, peer-reviewed, triple-blind studies, etc. So do I believe that the phenomena is occasionally real?
I do.
Do I necessarily think that that proves the existence of ghosts?
Not so fast!
My brain just popped.
Can you provide a link verifying Leslie Flint did take part in this experiment? Everything I've read seems to suggest that not only was he a fraud but that he actively avoided having his 'ability' tested.
You have to beware of certain sources related to these issues. Are you aware, for instance, that there are self-appointed "skeptic's brigades" (run by a woman named Susan Gerbic) which go to Wikipedia to doctor articles to slant them?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson has complained about them, because he keeps changing his Wikipedia page to "agnostic" and the skeptic brigades keep changing him to an "atheist".
He's tried to change his page dozens of times and they keep altering it to bring him in line with their own agenda.
You can see the article on Neil DeGrasse Tyson here: http://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/search?q=neil+degrasse+tyson+wikipedia&sort=relevance&t=all It's entitled: "TIL Neil deGrasse Tyson tried updating Wikipedia to say he wasn't atheist, but people kept putting it back".
My point in this?
The skeptic's brigades have been going around the internet, altering articles. And they've been busted for some pretty egregious (and deceptive) interpolations. Their goal? To turn neutral articles on the paranormal into slanted articles that favor their world view. For instance on an article about the Duke University studies, the actual sentence was: "The results were interesting, given the fact that they were higher than the calculated margin for coincidence." The skeptic's brigade altered it to: "The findings would have been interesting--had the underlying premise been sound. Which it was not."
You can Google the subject and see people's screen shots of the Before-and-After versions of online articles that had been doctored.
So beware Wikipedia articles on Leslie Flint. As with Neil DeGrasse Tyson, you're going to be getting the doctored version which in many cases has been altered to align with the worldview of The Amazing Randi (whose institute Susan Gerbic is associated with).
By the way, you can see a workshop where Miss Gerbic is coaching others on how to alter articles: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5FuJT9mp0jw
(Ironically, when the video clip starts they have a pic of Neil DeGrasse Tyson, who's annoyed at these very same people for their acts of intellectual vandalism and their attempts to co-opt him.)
OK, sure, we'll be wary of Wikipedia. Can you point to any other sources for the bellybutton story then? Because you seem to be the only person on the internet claiming it.
This is my biggest beef with them. They almost never go after the establishment, even when the establishment clearly lies or says silly things. Instead they go after easy soft targets that require little intellectual effort and that have no political or economic clout to fight back.
I am not claiming there is no value in debunking, for example, quack homeopathic remedies. But what about debunking the exaggerated claims of pharmaceutical companies? The latter are used by far more people and cost far more money. Where are the skeptics questioning the marketing of antidepressants based on weak statistical results when other studies show that they're likely no better than placebo?
Where were the skeptics during the run-up to the Iraq war? Where are they when the latest economic bubble is growing and "it's different this time?" There's been a minor epidemic of scientific fraud and retractions lately... where are the skeptics joining forces to call for more transparency and more repetition of existing experiments to validate their results?
Granted there are occasionally murmurs like that, but most skeptics just like to take pot shots at easy stuff.
Yeah, you nailed it. That's exactly my problem with them.
They'll attack a 2-lb monkey and ignore the 800-pound gorilla. "Look at the 13 people putting their health in peril by going to Phillipino psychic surgeons!"
Meanwhile, they're conspicuously silent on the 30 million people who died because of antidepressants whose efficacy rates were lower than placebos.
There were even more articles about mainstream medical fraud recently, with a meta-study done on the number of fraudulent studies pushed in journals. The rate for scientific fraud in America (if I remember correctly) was something like 30% higher than the rest of the world. (Here's an article on it: http://io9.com/5692788/new-study-shows-american-and-indian-scientists-are-the-most-fraudulent) Which is why most people respect studies from Scandinavia or Germany. But almost no one internationally trusts American studies (which are almost always funded by corporations with an interested motive).
"Cigarettes cause cancer? Nonsense! This study funded by R.J. Reynolds says that that's an urban myth!"
The state of America's pharmaceutical industry is a joke. Yet (as you point out) the self-appointed TV skeptics never counsel using your critical thinking faculties on the pharmaceutical industry.
Or the government.
Or any other powerful institution.
That was a surprisingly convincing argument you wrote there. Commenting here to come back later.
Anyone interested in psychics, frauds, and skeptics, should watch the film Red Lights. It's fiction, but it's got some great things in it that reference actual psychic and paranormal experiments similar to the ones listed.
Ultimately, it's up to those making outlandish claims to provide supporting evidence.
Are you a skeptic about the existence of Rumplestiltskin? If so, why?
First of all: Define "outlandish claims".
Every single discovery that's ever been made has, at one time, been called an "outlandish claim".
Like when Nikola Tesla shared his idea for "alternating current" with his professor at the Polytechnic, the man scoffed and said, "Son, what you're describing is a perpetual motion machine," and laughed.
The man immediately dismissed the concept as a pipe dream, and walked off.
Needless to say, the computer we're both using today is running off of alternating current.
So it wasn't a "perpetual motion" machine, and it wasn't "outlandish."
But at the time-period, people who should have known better acted as if it was.
Same thing with Edison's phonograph. A Professor deVille at the Sorbonne (who held a PhD in acoustics) claimed that Edison's invention was a hoax. "He's fooling people with ventriloquism". Well, more than a century later, deVille looks like an idiot. But at the time, he was the authority figure, and he swore up and down that Edison's invention was "outlandish" and impossible.
Yet there it was.
These days, many things that were once decried as outlandish have turned out to be true. Like the Higgs boson particle. Or how about Dark Matter? Or the growing evidence that the Holographic Universe model might actually have validity?
Theoretical physics is far, far stranger than anything served up to us from folklore.
What's one man's "outlandish" claim in 1902 is another man's "confirmed reality" in 2013.
I myself was freaked out when I learned that the statistical variance to "prove" the Higgs boson effect was lower than the stats they got while studying stuff like remote viewing and ESP. Which leads to an interesting quote by a professional skeptic who studies these things and debunks paranormal claims. Even he admits:
"I agree that by the standards of any other area of science that remote viewing and ESP is proven. But that begs the question: Do we need higher standards of evidence when we study the paranormal?"--Dr. Richard Wiseman
In other words, a statistical variance of say, .02% can be used to prove that the Higgs boson particle is real. But if you have a statistical variance of 3.2% for remote viewing, he claims, "Er . . . okay, okay. That looks really good. But we have to raise the threshold. What counts for other areas of science MUST NOT count for this one."
Why?
Because we use some arbitrary made-up-ass conception of "outlandish". Instead of going where the data leads us and using that as the standard [i.e., science], we demand higher thresholds of evidence than we use for anything else. In other words, certain people demand SUPER-science when approaching the paranormal. The stats for that must be higher than for anything else.
Why?
(I think it's because we ourselves are scared to challenge our own worldview. And that leads certain people to move the goalposts, so to speak. It's their way of cheating.)
If you examine it more closely, you realize that the common axiom you hear of "Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proof" is essentially un-scientific in its nature.
It's basically someone saying, "I'll hold you to the standard used by all other areas of science, and if you achieve it, I'll move the goal posts . . . and keep moving them . . . so that you'll never win."
That's not science. That's charlatanism.
I see two reasons:
We see no mechanism by which ESP and similar could work. Science is not merely about observations but also about creating mechanisms that explain the observations. So if we see no mechanism, people will normally try to refute that the observations are valid.
It is possible that research into ESP suffers from the drawer effect: the unsuccessful research is stuffed in the drawer while only the (accidentaly) successful research is promoted. This could not have happened with the Higgs boson (but it could happen with a great deal of f.e. psychological research, which is why we really might need higher standards of evidence in a lot of areas).
I, however, have my own opinion on these results although it is perhaps too complex to elaborate here.
Zzz. Wake me up when you have some peer reviewed studies in reputable journals.
[deleted]