[fb4F] My Bully Wanted to Take Home My Crush But Settled with Me
It started like any coming of age movie would be the loser nerd that had been bullied my whole life. That was going to be different when I saw my neighbor Paige and she said everyone was going to be at this house party across town before everyone left for college in the fall.
Paige had been my crush for as long as I can remember, she was a fixture of brightness in my life. I pulled up to Justin's house with his parents out of town and a keg of beer left from a labor day BBQ. It was on pace to be an exciting night. I didn't like drinking but I thought I would cut loose and live a little. The night started to flow nicely as I was lubricated with booze and went to chat with Paige, unfortunately talking with Victoria or as I thought of her Icky Vicky. Vicky would be probably the most attractive person our year or even at school if it wasn't for her ugly soul.
She apparently wasn't awful to everyone because she was smiling and jiggling with Paige, she even fixed Paige's flowing curly blonde lox out of her face. I didn't know when a girl was flirting with me but it seemed like Vicky was definitely trying to get with Paige.
"Hey Paige, thanks for telling me about the party!" I said as I cut in Vicky's stare made my heart stop but I pretended like she wasn't the devil I knew she was. "Oh of course, you know what I always looked for you at one of these and when I saw you I released that I should just tell you!" Paige's voice was the warmth of the sun and I nearly forgot completely about Vicky. "Oh sorry Vicky, but we can chat later!" She said to my bully. Vicky forced a smile before departing.
I thought that was it as the rest of the night went like a dream as Paige asked me to dance with her. She laughed at all of my jokes normally but she also started to touch my arm too. I decide to get another drunk after going to the bathroom and ask Paige if she wanted to walk home together. But the next thing I can remember is stumbling out on Justin's lawn as a person holding me up as my body felt so heavy.
I looked over to see Vicky pulling me along with my arm over my shoulder even though it seemed like she wanted to just start carrying me. I was confused and my vision was blurry but I heard an angel's voice calling out. "Hey wait! Paid called out before running up." Oh woah you look trashed." She said studying me. Vicky cut in quickly." Yeah this dweeb is a lightweight but I'll get him home. " A sweetness that tasted like venom. " Oh are you sure, we are neighbors so I can drive him home." My eyes brightened up as I thought I was saved. " Oh no, me and them go way back and I haven't had anything to drink so I should. I don't want your night to end already." Well technically true she did know me longer that only made her torture longer term. I tried to say I wanted to go with Paige but I just slurred nonsense, before I blacked out again.
The next time I came to I opened my eyes to bright neon signs flashing in a store window and Vicky getting back in her car with a bag. "Oh hey there cutie. You know that you really cock blocked me back there." She said matter of fact her tone was plain and her normal meanness. "I will say you at least have good taste. Paige is so hot! I was going to slip something in her drink if flirting didn't work but God do girls guard their drinks. I wish the girls that played defense on the soccer team had that much hustle we would have made it to state. I can't block every shot on the goal." I looked over, unable to form words in my mouth as I looked at her. She was driving and kept talking." Oh yeah, so you really left your cup out and full before going pee. God I knew you were stupid but fuck! I gave you a little extra but I think I might have over done it. You probably weigh less than Paige. Oh so I couldn't get a girl to have fun with tonight so I decided to make you a girl instead. " She laughed and it made me sick before I passed out again.
I woke up again and a headache was starting to form as I pulled my eyes open and I looked around a girl's room and I was laying in the bed... Naked! I let out a little surprised squeak, my voice. Still mostly slurred as I started to move. I found my hands stuck above my head and a hand pressed on my stomach. "Shhh be a good girl and don't struggle, I'm almost done with making you all pretty!" I heard Vicky say her voice softer and almost hungry as she put down a razor. I realized I was naked as she giggled. "Don't be embarrassed sweetie some girls have cock's and yours is cute!"
(Hey, if you read that all thanks! And if you would want to play Vicky please message me and I would love to hear from you! I could also see a cute a scene with Paige taking me into her house as I stumbled home still dressed up in a cute little outfit from Vicky's with tears smearing my face after I was despoiled by my bully! I'm open to hear any ideas and excited to hear from you!)
Posted Sep 11, 2025, 4:54 PM UTC