Amy's watch is pictured
In the Netflix docu, E3, about 31:00, her gf is talking about how they met up a few days before Amy left on the cruise. She's narrating "She wanted me to see her apartment" as they flash a photo on the screen of Amy in her new apt., surrounded by boxes.
She's wearing a watch on her left wrist (not her right, as the missing posters have said) and it has a black band. This appears to be the same watch shown in earlier photos - in earlier photos it has a white face.
This is not a silver watch with a blue face. In an FBI interview that's shown in the docu (I think E2, about 4 minutes in) Ron describes it as a "silver men's watch."
One commenter said that silver might be a description of the frame around the watch face, where the frame attaches to the band. Maybe, but that's a funky way to describe a watch with a black band. And no one ever corrected the photoshop example on the website.
It just doesn't seem likely that she would wear this black watch a few days before the cruise but bring a different watch on the cruise. It could happen, of course. But this is yet another photo that seems like it should have the Dos Equis watch but it doesn't.
Whatever she's wearing on her left wrist in the disco, it seems fairly shiny and silvery. It's hard to tell, but it might just be her silver bracelet. (Which I wouldn't describe as "thin" as it's described on the missing posters. It's a wide band, about the width of a men's watch. But it's the only silver bracelet that appears in any other photos.) It's more common to put on a bracelet to go dancing than it is to put on a watch.
The cruise photos don't show her wearing a thin bracelet or her class ring or the infamous Dos Equis watch. It does show a necklace that the posters don't mention. It's hard to tell in the disco - I think the necklace is still there but I'm not positive. Unless she's wearing a watch in the disco instead of a bracelet, there are no photos of any watch at all on the cruise.
So there are multiple discrepancies:
-
We never see her class ring on the cruise.
-
We never see a thin silver bracelet on the cruise. We see a wide one in previous photos, and that's what she might be wearing on her left wrist. The missing posters say the bracelet is on her left wrist.
-
We never see a Dos Equis watch anywhere. Or a silver watch. Or a silver watch with a blue face. We do see a black watch with a white face. It's possible she's wearing that (or the Dos Equis watch) in the disco, but it's possible that's just her bracelet.
-
She's wearing a necklace that is never mentioned.
How could the Bradleys be so wrong about her jewelry? They've had 27 years, plus photos and videos, to correct themselves.
It seems like the class ring would still be with her things from her apartment. How could the Bradleys miss that? If they missed that, did they miss the Dos Equis watch, too? Maybe both those things are up in the attic.
How did they get mixed up about the bracelet? There are photos of Amy wearing it before the cruise. You can see it's not thin. She's wearing something in the disco that could be her wide bracelet but there's no thin bracelet in any of the photos I've seen - on the cruise or anytime before that. Unless they mean the metal itself is hammered thin. If so, these people are very bad at descriptions.
Posted Sep 13, 2025, 10:51 PM UTC