Medicated/Natural FET cycle

Looking for some input on your thoughts or experiences. We had our first fully medicated FET on August 14th. and it did not work. The day of FET, the embryo was not hatching on its own and they did assisted hatching. Fast forward to now, September, my dr recommended we do a modified natural cycle (no bc prep, PIO shots, etc.) and I am unsure how to feel. My mental health tanked on a medicated cycle. I really thought the first transfer would work with a perfect embryo and a beautiful 10 mm triliminar lining. For some backstory, we have 4 AB tested embryos. This next transfer in October will be an identical 4AB embryo as well. Has anyone had any experience with medicated vs. natural? Im a 27 year old female with no prior health issues, we are male factor. Ladies, please give me any advice, thoughts, or success stories with medicated/natural FET. Did your second FET take? Im in limbo mentally with all this.