[Announcement] Glenn Greenwald will host a Q&A in /r/IAMA today 1:00 PM ET

The government might be shut down, but Reddit certainly isn't! Today at 1:00 PM ET Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald will host an AMA session about his converge of the NSA leaks and more.

Edward Snowden didn't reveal the extent of the US government's domestic spying programs all alone. He entrusted the information he leaked to a number of journalists, perhaps most prominently The Guardian's Glenn Greenwald. Now, after facing persecution from the UK government, which arrested and detained Greenwald's partner for nine hours, and separately destroyed some of The Guardian's hard drives, both Glenn Greenwald and his editor Janine Gibson will host a Reddit AMA (Ask Me Anything) to answer your questions about the leaked NSA files.

For all interested parties, please click here to check out the AMA.

Thanks!

Posted Oct 1, 2013, 2:48 PM UTC · edited

5164
bacteriadude•

sweet! I'd like to know if he feels personally vulnerable (given his partner was detained at heathrow), and what he thinks people in his position can do to

  • avoid being slandered

  • avoid persecution

3
zotquix•

His partner who had thousands of sensitive documents on his laptop? Or Glenn who lied and misrepresented parts of the Snowden story to make it more sensational.

Oh, I'm sorry am I persecuting the liar by acknowledging the fact that some of things he said were in fact lies that have been debunked?

-4
space_walrus•

Which lies? There's a bit of he said she said, but it appears that the only documents Glenn's partner gave up were the recipes on his laptop. Miranda had no passwords for the secret documents he carried.

1
zotquix•

Some of the most misleading stuff was claims about what roles various companies played in surveillance. Greenwald presented it in a totally misleading fashion compared to what the truth turned out to be. Then the WaPo ran with it and didn't even bother to run a retraction when they found out they were wrong.

0
yorrick21•

Of all the stupid things you could have possibly said, you picked the stupidest.

Are you a living, breathing pile of dog shit... or do you just think like one?

-4
zotquix•

Uh oh, someone's mad. XD

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Phuqued•

I want him to explain why every single article he's written regarding these leaks admits that a warrant is needed for actual eavesdropping on US persons, but that admission is usually buried somewhere around the 20th paragraph, below a whole story of sensationalist misdirection.

I would like you to explain how every article you've read of Glenn's that you failed to grasp his argument about how a warrant issued in secret is not a traditional value of Western Civilization, and is more common with governments and institutions that oppress their own people, making a mockery of civil rights and the basic notions of justice.

Go ahead, I want to hear the brilliance that contradicts hundreds of years of western philosophy on transparent and open justice.

6
footnote4•

I'd like you to explain the difference in principle between a warrant issued in secret and one not done so, especially when the warrant obviously concerns classified information that could actually be damaging if released. You just asserted that secret warrants run against the spirit of Western civilization, without actually making any convincing argument for why that is so. That's not a compelling comeback - it's just stipulating something to be true. The role of a warrant is to ensure that an impartial party with the legal training to ascertain the reasonableness of a government's request gets to pass judgment before a search can be conducted. That purpose is satisfied whether a warrant is given in open court or in a secret court. Obviously, secret warrants might be troublesome if there were no good reason for them, but in fact, there is an extremely good reason for them - they are being sought in cases where the revelation of national security information could be legitimately dangerous.

You do understand that not all court actions are open, right? Like, you know that divorce records are usually sealed, right? You understand that records are often sealed where a party has an interest in maintaining a degree of secrecy with respect to information revealed during the proceedings of the court? You know that grand juries meet in secret? In the judicial system, openness and secrecy are oftentimes instrumental values toward the achievement of other substantive values, rather than ends in and of themselves. Where there is good reason to keep something secret, there is nothing wrong with preventing information from being released.

In any case, you have failed to address the main point of the question, which is that it is fundamentally dishonest to fail to disclose the procedural safeguards in place until 20 paragraphs in.

1
Phuqued•

I'd like you to explain the difference in principle between a warrant issued in secret and one not done so,

So are you saying that you can't figure out that difference? That a secret warrant is not accountable because it's secret? You can't figure out all the potential abuse for this?

especially when the warrant obviously concerns classified information that could actually be damaging if released.

I swallowed this spoonful of garbage before from the GWB Administration on Iraq and WMD. "We know they have them, but the information secret because if released it might compromise our intelligence assets that gave it to us." Do you know how that turned out?

  1. Defector Admits to Lies about WMD
  2. Yellow Cake Debunked a Year before by U.S. Intelligence Befor Bush Repeated It

I could go on, but really what's the point? If you honestly still buy the bullshit government is selling to keep you enslaved, then you deserve to be a slave of the system that want's to control you.

You just asserted that secret warrants run against the spirit of Western civilization, without actually making any convincing argument for why that is so.

I made a convincing argument, you're just too stupid and ignorant to understand it. But start with the Magna Carta and go from there.

The role of a warrant is to ensure that an impartial party with the legal training to ascertain the reasonableness of a government's request gets to pass judgment before a search can be conducted.

Except, what happens when that warrant can't be challenged or revealed because of secrecy? Are you telling me that people like Hoover don't exist in the upper levels of our government, where they use information to compromise people, even judges? If your actions can't be held accountable, are people going to push the envelope of what is proper and just? Yes they will.

To quote Madison: “If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.”

I could go on, but really responding to you is boring the shit out of me and trying my patience. I have better things to do than waste my time trying to educate the equivalent Frito from the movie Idiocracy.

3
footnote4•

That a secret warrant is not accountable because it's secret? You can't figure out all the potential abuse for this?

Okay, you actually don't understand the purpose that warrants serve in the criminal justice system. Warrants don't exist to be a public record of conduct for the citizenry to inspect; they exist to ensure that an unbiased, disinterested party with a high level of legal training and skill - a judge - passes judgment on the lawfulness of a search of seizure before permitting it. That function has little to do with whether a warrant is public or private.

I swallowed this spoonful of garbage before from the GWB Administration on Iraq and WMD.

No, with all due respect, that isn't good enough. You can't just say that because a president lied, we should now always distrust the government whenever it does anything related to national security. Sorry, that isn't a persuasive or valid argument. In any case, the Bush Administration did not claim that releasing info on the proof that Iraq possessed WMDs would be harmful to security interests, they just made up fake proof. That situation isn't even analogous to the one we're discussing.

If you honestly still buy the bullshit government is selling to keep you enslaved, then you deserve to be a slave of the system that want's to control you.

No I don't, and that's a terrible thing to say. This comment says a lot more about your immaturity than my values. One might respond that if you're willing to endanger your lives and others by making it easier for terrorists to carry out attacks then you deserve to die in an act of terrorism, but that would be an awful, inhuman thing to say.

you're just too stupid and ignorant to understand it.

Again, this says a lot more about your inability to control your temper than me.

But start with the Magna Carta and go from there.

Lol, no. All you did was post a link to a wikipedia article about the Magna Carta. For all I know, you don't even understand it - that's like me supporting a point about constitutional law by just linking to the Constitution, or supporting some other claim by just linking to the front page of the New York Times. Nope, doesn't cut it.

Except, what happens when that warrant can't be challenged or revealed because of secrecy? Are you telling me that people like Hoover don't exist in the upper levels of our government, where they use information to compromise people, even judges? If your actions can't be held accountable, are people going to push the envelope of what is proper and just? Yes they will.

I think we've arrived at the central fallacy of your argument. A warrant that has been granted by a judge can't be challenged regardless of whether it was granted in secret or publicly. Did you really not know that? Ordinary citizens are not permitted to challenge warrants granted by judges. For the purpose of oversight, then, it makes no difference whether a warrant is granted in public or secret - we can't do anything about a warrant in either case once it has been granted. This point is absolutely central to your argument, and on it, you are totally wrong.

you is boring the shit out of me

I'm boring the shit out of you so much that you felt the compulsion to type out a long response to me. Get real.

and trying my patience

Then get some patience. That says more about your personality flaw than about me.

I have better things to do than waste my time

No you don't. Revealed preferences, man.

the equivalent Frito from the movie Idiocracy.

Again, your frequent resort to ad hominem attacks says a lot more about your anger than about me.

0
backpackwayne•

Yea he probably won't answer that part.

-2
Shredder13•

Because that doesn't sell page views.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Shredder13•

Well that was lame.

1
Harsh_Marsh•

Woo

1
AmericanDerp•

Wonder how many NSA staff will tune in and/or down vote to bury questions. Ask the wrong question and enjoy getting analyzed clandestinely and illegally, US citizens.

Wassup, Fort Meade in da house.

0
jzpenny•

And this is one reason why this blanket surveillance is so dangerous. An American public that is afraid to speak its mind about important civic issues for fear of official retaliation is no longer a free people.

4
AmericanDerp•

Yup.

0
Shredder13•

No, it's just paranoia and what is known as "Being a pussy".

0
jzpenny•

By the standards of Martin Luther King, Gandhi, Washington, Jesus... most human beings are pussies. We aren't willing to stand up for what we know is right if the risk to our own comfort or safety is too great. That is how things like Stalinism and Hitlerism take hold over a people... the people are convinced to trade liberty for safety. They surrender to authority rather than fight against injustice, always convincing themselves that they are safer saying nothing, because the authorities are not coming for them. They forget that the authorities have only failed to come after them yet, and that the only guarantee that they will not be next proceeds from justice, not servility.

Now is the time to stand up against injustice, to draw a "red line" of our own against the forces pushing us down the slippery slope of oppression. So, in a way, I agree with you.

In another way, though, I know that oppression does happen. It is forever the temptation suffered by powerful men to quash those who dissent. It has happened here in America and it will again. This warrantless blanket surveillance is an invaluable tool of oppression in the wrong hands, and for that reason I disagree with what you say, because these fears people have are absolutely not unfounded or inconsequential.

We all like to envision ourselves as George Washingtons or Oskar Schindlers, standing up bravely against oppressive forces at great risk to ourselves... but that is so much self-delusion. As history clearly shows, most people are meek and silent collaborators with oppressors, usually out of fear. To discount the effectiveness of that fear as a motivator is actually to dilute the heroism of the few who do stand up against it, to call the impossibly hard work they have done, the terror they have confronted, and the blood they have shed no more than average and unremarkable. It is anything but. Heroism is a rare quality, but it is one we all should strive for, especially we Americans.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Shredder13•

Looks like none.

3
YankeeQuebec•

LOL. Their shills already already here spreading disinformation.

Great. Another libertarian circle-jerk. Just what we needed.

.

Is Glenn coming to reddit because no one else will have him?

Oh snap. That was a classic comment if I've ever seen one. Bravo to you.

.

Why aren't you asking instead about the need to make N.S.A. noise while the libertarians(TeaPublicans) are destroying the U.S. economy?

.

Yes I know..., and it's getting real old.

.

Your story of the century has mucked up r/politics more than any other subject ever. To even imply it has not got enough coverage is the epitome of whining.

Those account for a quarter of the comments in this thread already.

Edit: Added more examples of how close minded individuals, look to shutter any conversation that doesn't fit their agend.

-3
backpackwayne•

LOL. Already calling people shills who don't agree with you. That is the definition of a circlejerk.

6
hsfuzj42ZL•

While it is true that not all dissenters are shills, it is also true that there are organized campaigns toward pro-authority stances on social media.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-operation-social-networks

http://www.infosecisland.com/blogview/12250-HBGary-Federal-Document-on-Manipulating-Social-Media.html

5
Shredder13•

Wow, look at all that proof and hard evidence!

2
YankeeQuebec•

There you go, adding nothing to the conversation.

The only circlejerk in here, is the one you're perpetuating about there being a libertarian circlejerk.

Denial is the first step to acceptance.

-7
backpackwayne•

The conversation has been beat to death and you listen to nothing anyone has to say. We are all shills because we don't join in your obsession. In case you didn't notice our government is shut down and I don't give a rat's ass about your whiny-ass obsession. You are worse than the republicans with their never-dying mission to end Obamcare. I didn't think that was possible but it is true.

If you guys actually debated, it might be interesting. But the only debating going here is the masture-debating.

9
backpackwayne•

My guess is all of them.

-4
Shredder13•

All zero.

0
Armchair_Marxist•

Seriously?

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
wrathborne•

Gonna be one big D-dos attack at about 1:05PM today on reddit.

-4
Mr_Pricklepants•

Not happening.

7
Grenshen4px•

itshappening.gif

3
backpackwayne•

Great. Another libertarian circle-jerk. Just what we needed.

-8
[deleted]•

Dude. Circle jerks are fun. The biscuits and gravy are delicious.

3
backpackwayne•

Can't say no to biscuits and gravy.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
backpackwayne•

The simple fact is is we knew about years ago. Just because you want to pretend it only started a few months ago doesn't make it the new apocalypse. And just because you freak out over it doesn't mean it is not legal. Move along..., nothing to see here.

3
Phuqued•

The simple fact is is we knew about years ago.

We knew nothing. We suspected.

Just because you want to pretend it only started a few months ago doesn't make it the new apocalypse.

Knowing is understanding. We didn't know before the Snowden leaks because it was all secret. The reach and capabilities are not what I was taught to believe in about America or the West. Rather these approaches to governance were criticized by the west as inferior, authoritarian and counter productive to to human/civil rights.

And just because you freak out over it doesn't mean it is not legal.

The fact that you aren't concerned is disturbing. But what is even more disturbing is your inability to distinguish between legal, and morally / ethically right. Say we pass a law that allows anyone to commit one act of murder without consequence, regardless of method. Would you still reason that it is "legal" and thus nothing to see here and to move along?

1
Freeman001•

Bpw is a GrC troll. Don't bother.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Shredder13•

Lrn2readingconprehension

-1
TodaysIllusion•

Is Glenn coming to reddit because no one else will have him?

-8
jzpenny•

He's been on virtually every major media outlet.

8
TodaysIllusion•

No, you are wrong, the so called MSM is not going to attack this program, they benefit from it, support it, are part of it.

-2
jzpenny•

No, you are wrong

No I'm not. Greenwald has been interviewed a ton lately.

9
TodaysIllusion•

Why aren't you asking instead about the need to make N.S.A. noise while the libertarians(TeaPublicans) are destroying the U.S. economy?

-4
backpackwayne•

Yes I know..., and it's getting real old.

-3
jzpenny•

That's your opinion. Mine is basically the opposite: this is story of the century material and deserves way more coverage than it is receiving. I'm thankful to Glenn for doing the AMA and hope the media exposure continues to grow. People need to know about this, they need to understand the real-life implications on democracy and our national political conversation when the discussion is chilled by an intimidating perception of the lack of privacy.

7
backpackwayne•

Your story of the century has mucked up r/politics more than any other subject ever. To even imply it has not got enough coverage is the epitome of whining.

-5
backpackwayne•

Oh snap. That was a classic comment if I've ever seen one. Bravo to you.

-6