I have been catfished on levels previously unknown to humanity

Please tell me I'm not insane and the picture looks exactly 12% similar to the record I ordered. It was cheap and I'm not emotionally invested, I literally just bought it to display because it looked cool and I was buying a birthday gift from the same store, but what turned up is absolutely not being framed and hung up on my wall.

Does this warrant contacting the record store? It's now sold out so they can't even send me a better one if it is just a manufacturing thing, but it's a totally different kind of glitter so how could it be? I don't know, I'm rambling. I'm not actually that mad but it is quite disappointing the picture was so misleading.