[Set Mechanic Idea] Dynamic Classes

DISCUSSION

I want to start this post by stating that I'm just a Emerald scrub, with little notion on how unbalanced this idea might be. I'm a bit stupid so I'm not able to think that far ahead. English is also not my first language, so I apologize in advance for any possible errors in the text.

THE IDEA

Every unit has an origin and a class (or even two), right? But what if, every match, their classes could change, randomly, between a set number of classes?

I'm not talking about a mechanic like Set 15's Lee Sin, where you get to choose which class he'll be using when you place him on the field. What I'm suggesting is the following:

  • Imagine that every unit (or just units from a specific tier, like 4 costs and 5 costs) has two possible classes, with a different ability in each class;

  • When a match starts, the game randomly decides which class that unit will be using on that match;

  • For example, take Samira from Set 15. She is a Soul Fighter / Edgelord. But, in this scenario, she could also be a Soul Fighter / Sniper, with a different ability that could focus on her firing multiple rounds at an enemy from afar.

  • For another example, let's take Darius: he's a Supreme Cell / Heavyweight, but what if he could also be a Supreme Cell / Juggernaut, with an ability similiar to Set 14 Darius, spinning his axe and healing himself?

I think you get the idea. With this mechanic, every unit would be randomly placed with one of their two classes, which would change every match. I don't mean to say that either all units would be using Class 1 in one match, and Class 2 in another match. I think the randomness should apply to every unit individually, with thousands of different possibilities that a match could have.

THE POSITIVES

  • I think this mechanic would make the game dynamic, and would possibly render tier lists useless (since you wouldn't be able to play a certain comp in the same way all the time).

  • It would bring some freshness every match and raise the skill ceiling.

THE NEGATIVES

  • It could be a balancing nightmare (not as much as Power Ups, but still)

  • Clarity could be an issue. A certain UI element would be necessary so players could check which classes the units are in that match

  • It would certainly be harder for the dev team to develop, since they would basically need to create every unit twice (or less, if this mechanic only applied to a certain tier of units)

I'm certain that there are more positives points and more negative points to add, but I didn't think it too much. It's just an idea. What do you guys think?

Posted Oct 2, 2025, 3:33 PM UTC

06

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 6 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.