would you rather? (versus edition)

would you rather play versus with a rusher who leaves everyone behind or play with someone who plays like a bot. this “bot” has late reaction time, always going down, gets pinned by zombies a lot and knows how to play but sucks. the rusher is somewhat good, speed runs every chapter, and to make it more interesting the rusher is toxic in chat when/if they die. rules are you cannot kick them, the enemy team has neither of these people, both players have no mic, both players are not strategically good with special infected, they will always be the tank, and you have to try and win. which teammate are yall going with