The Scythe and Rapier are usually cited as good Frigates for the early game, which do you prefer?

I just unlocked the Rapier and am ready for an upgrade! I have enough coins for either the Scythe or the Rapier, but I'm having a hard time deciding between the two! Various tier lists have them at the same ranking, and while I'm intrigued by the Scythe, my Valkyrie eats through those in ranked matches...

Decisions, decisions!