Same Design Multiple Listings?

Hello,

Would it make sense to have the same design on multiple t-shirt options? I was thinking of having the lighter and more affordable and lighter Gildan 64000 with a design, and then the AS Color Staple T as a medium weight one. I am worried that it would end up cluttering and confusing people. Should I just commit to one brand and type to stock?

Obviously doing a hat or hoodie would be ok. I just mean for the same type of garment.

Thanks for your thoughts

Best, BHN