I feel like I've tried everything but I know the people of reddit can help me. 

40yo female. My skin is dry/normal. I wear makeup 1-2x a week, and when I do, I'd like a light coverage. I thought tinted moisturizer would be good for that. 

This has happened with Clinique moisture surge Shear tint hydrator, Neutrogena healthy skin anti-aging perfector, and Neutrogena radiant tinted Moisturizer. 

I thought maybe it was part of my routine, so I tried skipping each/all of those. Nothing changed when skipping daily SPF moisturizer (Aveeno), niacinamide (The Ordinary) or my Vitamin C (No 7 Radiance). 

I read that maybe it's because my skin was too dry, so today I made sure to be extra moisturized and even used some water on my fingers, which really seemed to work at first. But then by the time I get to where I'm really trying to rub it in, it starts rolling/pilling on me.

The last picture of my eyebrows is crazy, I know- I don't usually rub it into my eyebrows but as I was trying to get the rest off it really shows how bad it was. Whenever this happens I have to wipe everything off with a washcloth and completely start over.

Maybe I need to use a brush or sponge? Maybe tinted moisturizer is not for me? I also got some Maybelline Fit Me foundation to try later this week. 

All tinted moisturizers roll up on my face?? Going crazy