r/nfl•
someone447

With Manning having an absolutely ridiculous year--how do you rank the 4 elite QBs?

Inspired by this thread, I'm curious as to what everyone thinks.

Personally, I have them ranked:

  1. Rodgers

  2. Manning

  3. Brady

  4. Brees

I've been hearing quite a few people say that Manning is better than Rodgers, but I just don't think 5 games is a big enough sample size--especially since Rodgers has outperformed Manning the past 5 years.

Agree? Disagree?

Edit: I'm talking about right now. I think Manning is playing better than Rodgers, but I don't believe he is the better QB right now. Kind of like how in 2010 Arian Foster outperformed Adrian Peterson, but Peterson was the better RB.

Posted Oct 11, 2013, 7:35 AM UTC · edited

016
Loading comments…