Surface Book 3 - Surface Connect port USB3 failure??
Subject says a lot here but I'll explain further.
I have a 13.5" SB3 with the "performance" keyboard base. It was my wife's main computer for a while, but we replaced it because it was having problems with its connection to the keyboard base - it would randomly disconnect even when it wasn't being moved, and would sometimes BSOD the laptop. After "retiring" it (got her a Framework 13), I gently hit the Surface Connect port with contact cleaner using a "Pureport" iPhone Lightning cleaning kit, and it seemed to be working OK. So I put it into use as a secondary / test system at home (to run VMs and such).
I've been trying to use it with a Surface Dock to add wired ethernet, display output, and additional USB ports.
The "built-in" USB3 ports on the keyboard base work correctly. But anything on the Surface Dock (v1) will only connect if it is USB2.x. If I connect a USB3 flash drive to the dock, the SBook never even acknowledges its existence. The only way I can get it to see a USB3 device is to put a USB2.0 hub between the Dock and the device (to force it down to 2.0 speed).
While troubleshooting this, I picked up a (used and cheap, thankfully) Surface Dock 2 (with USB-C instead of Mini-DP). On this dock, the built-in ethernet doesn't even show up at all... I'm assuming that on the Dock2 the ethernet controller is wired to USB3, while on the Dock1 it must be USB2. I do get video output from the USB-C ports though! (I didn't have a mini-DP to fullsize DP adapter to test with the Dock1, but I do have USB-C to DP adapters.)
In an effort to rule out problems, I have tried splitting the Book from the keyboard and attaching both Docks directly to the slate's Surface Connect port, and the same problems persist there. It seems to me like whatever handles the USB3 "passthrough" on the connector is somehow messed up?
Is this a failure that is common or has been seen in this subreddit? I really hate to trash an otherwise functional device over this, but inability to use all functions from the Dock is really quite annoying for my needs. Given how "integrated" the whole thing is I imagine that a repair would be tricky... The connectors themselves look OK to my eye, I don't see any obvious mangled fingers or anything. I'm worried it's an internal fuse or something else board-level that would cost $several-hundred to fix (at which point I'd rather just put the money toward a replacement or a NUC-type device for my use case).
Posted Oct 15, 2025, 8:59 PM UTC