Help me choose a guerlain l’art fragrance for my friend

Hey everyone, hope all is well! Me and buddy of mine have had a tradition every Christmas to buy each other fragrances, it’s mainly been blind buying new houses that we haven’t smelled / don’t own any fragrances from. This year I’m planning on getting him a guerlain l’art fragrance and needed your help picking, I can’t smell any where I’m at so I’m just going to order the one that I feel fits best, I’ve narrowed it down to a few of them but i need some insight from people who have smelled / own these bottles.

He likes cherry fragrances, tobacco and neroli so I’m a bit torn between these 3: cherry oud, neroli outrenoir and tobacco honey.

I’m thinking cherry oud is looking like the best one without a doubt, second place maybe tobacco honey but he has Naxos, not sure if they are very similar or not, he loves neroli portofino by tom ford but he dislikes its performance so if the neroli one smelled similar and performs better then that one sounds good aswell.

If you have smelled/own these fragrances, mind letting me know how they are and which one to pick?

Thanks and cheers in advance!