Help me decide I can only buy one now

Hey all I'm deciding between these two tops. I can't afford both right now. I just got the Maritime sweatpants so I'm tempted to get the matching Coaster Luxe but I have been wanting a sweater in the Seasoft material. I have the seasoft pants in Waterloo and teal. So it won't match.

Just wanted to see what folks thought of both of these (I have two other Luxe sweaters).

Thanks!