An Unreasonable First Rule?

My wife and I just made our first rule in polyamory, after both of us have agreed that rules basically don't work (we think they simply carry on the old "ownership" paradigm that monogamy uses and that transgressions of rules become about breaking the rule rather than the thing that the rule was created to stop), and thus, I feel uneasy. I thought I'd pose the situation to the good people of r/polyamory and see if people think I'm being unreasonable in my safety concern.
My wife is dating (and when I say "dating", I mean having sex with) another man whose wife is dating another man, whose wife is dating a man and a woman. The woman is in an otherwise monogamous relationship with her husband, that is, like me, he is not seeing anyone else and this puts us at opposite ends of the sex chain. The man she is seeing is a swinger and the chain of people has virtually no end where he is linked in. The two of them use condoms, no one else wants to: that is, everyone else wishes to be fluid-bonded (fb).
I believe that because the chain is open at one end, fb is too risky and would allow an STI to work its way down the chain. I think that each primary couple can be fb, but that the secondaries should use (I know I can only influence my wife's decision here, not other folks in the chain) condoms to prevent this. I have requested that my wife use condoms and she is doing so, but unhappily as she believes that the odds of something coming down the chain before it is discovered by quarterly testing (although she can only influence her secondary's decision on getting tested this frequently, I believe it will be less frequent with the others) are slim to none, and closer to none. She thinks the rule: "If the chain is open, condoms are used; if the chain is closed, fb is fine" is too hard line and should be agreed upon as a case by case basis rather than a rigid rule.
A final note: communication with this group of people regarding safety issues has so far been rife with misinformation, miscommunication, and misunderstanding. I do not trust how information is disseminated through the chain.

What do you think o' minds of reddit?

Posted Oct 20, 2013, 11:07 PM UTC · edited

1815
pums•

I think using condoms with others (when you have a primary/secondary kind of framework) is a really good safety rule regardless of whether your group is theoretically open or closed because the bigger your group is, the less you can count on everyone actually being faithful/honest. It's one thing to trust your spouse, but you have no particular reason to trust your spouse's partners and all of their partners partners etc. Sexual health rules which require a lot of people you don't know that well to act in a certain way really put your health in their hands. So, while I agree with your concern regarding this person with various other sexual partners, my STD concerns with this wouldn't end with them. If you make a "condoms always with other partners rule", this will be less like you're judging this particular guy's sexual behavior (and by extension, his partner's partner and eventually your wife), or how the group is operating.
I'd also try to talk to your wife about how she feels about the possibly of contracting STDs. It's possible that your disagreement stems not from different senses of risk but different beliefs about the acceptability of contracting something, and it might help to talk about that.

21
TraneRideOP•

No, we have talked about it, it stems from different senses of risk. Thanks for the advice :)

3
Narayume•

I don't believe in unreasonable rules - everyone has to decide for themselves what they consider reasonable. In your case I see the options as: Either she uses condoms with everyone but you or the two of you start using condoms. She can decide herself which she prefers. For what it is worth - I agree with you that her not using condoms is a serious risk and I would not be comfortable with it.

19
[deleted]•

Keep it simple. Keep it smart. Condoms 100% of the time.

9
Theturkeylegs•

Condoms. Always. At least in our relationship. It's not about what either of my partners are doing(becuase I know who they are doing) but who their partners partners partners are doing,etc.

Is that worth the gamble? Nope.

I will say I am fb with my secondary, although we use condoms as our chosen method of birth control. However that was not a decision taken lightly, and does not involve a chain of anyone or anything.

8
bbb4246🍍•

she believes that the odds of something coming down the chain before it is discovered by quarterly testing... are slim to none, and closer to none.

Chlamydia spreads like wildfire. Unless they're only having sex quarterly, getting tested quarterly is not going to do much good.

8
PasswordIsntHAMSTER•

As someone who caught herpes and then went back into singledom, dating when you have a permanent STI is a BITCH. Probably not applicable in your case, but I felt like venting.

8
SEGirl•

Hugs

5
conservative_poly•

I am in a closed group of five people, spread out into a "W". Three and the other two were fluidbonded before I met my GF. After about a year of this constellation and me using condoms with my GF, we had a talk and decided that in this constellation it's OK to be "all" fluidboned - as long as we stay closed and that any outside action has to be with condoms!

I would never have agreed to fb with us being an open group. And maybe not in a bigger goup. Or with less responsible people.

And you described that communication is problematic through the whole group and that you do possibly not even know who's in this group and how responsible those people are. With this I would judge the risk as big as hitting up someone in a nice bar and having unprotected sex. Some do that, some think it's too risky.

7
Ford_Prefect2nd•

I think if you don't want to have a "rule" simply alter how you treat it. Explain YOU do not want an STI, and if she is exposing herself, YOU will not. So she will have to decide who she is fb with.

Other than that, yeah man, that seems crazy to me; I would never sleep with a new person without a condom, and given your wife's boyfriend is -sexual exposure speaking- potentially a new person every time she sees him, she is playing with fire. The fact that she can burn you, is that much worse. There are plenty of STI that can take months to show visible symptoms. That's plenty of time between quarterly checks for everyone in fun town to move the sti ghetto.

6
AbsoluteElsewhere•

My wife and I just made our first rule in polyamory, after both of us have agreed that rules basically don't work...and thus, I feel uneasy.

Here's my take. It's great to have philosophical arguments, discussions about breaking down paradigms, etc. However, philosophy and practicality seldom mesh 100% of the time. My relationships with my partners only work when we come up with practical solutions that work for everyone involved. That might involve preserving invisible hierarchies, but I'm not trying to start a revolution. I'm just trying to share love with the people in my life and do right by them, as well as getting my needs met. So if we decide a rule works for us, I'm not going to stress about it preserving some abstract philosophy. EDIT: grammar

4
vrimj•

I think instead of rules you should make an appointment to go together to planned parenthood or some other good source of information and discuss the situation with an educated professional who doesn't have an emotional stake (and get your own testing if needed and talk hep B and viral mengitis vaccine )

3
TraneRideOP•

Great idea. Thank you :)

5
justaddsalt•

I would like to note that a practical solution is that you wear condoms while with your wife if she is not wearing condoms in this whole open circle thing. You can only do so much to convince someone else to protect themselves, but you can take your safety into your own hands.

Personally, I would suggest telling her that you do not feel comfortable with being fb with an open circle, and that if she isn't going to wear condoms with her partners, you wish to wear condoms while with her.

You can lecture her all you want about safety, but you can only lead a horse to water. You can't make the horse drink.

3
whycreeperswhyy•

I think that rule in this case is totally fair. Agree with the other posters saying that if she doesn't want her freedom limited, she can choose condoms with him or condoms with you.

I'm confused as to what she means by case by case basis, it seems like this is a case that she brought up and you've assessed it and think it's too risky. Doesn't seem like that hard of a line to me, you're concerned about her health and yours!

2