Short zoom for Z mount

Anyone done a comparison of the following 3 lenses? -Tamron 16-30mm f/2.8 for Nikon Z -Nikon Z 17-28mm f/2.8 (Tamron rebadge, right?) -Nikon Z 14-30mm f/4 S

I'm learning that I like wide lenses, and I'd hopefully be replacing my Irix 15mm f/2.4 with a short zoom that has weather sealing and could be used interchangeably for landscape, astro/night sky, cityscape. They all appear to be pretty close in price, and I'm more of a creative shooter (not concerned with clinical sharpness or edge to edge sharp wide open, character is appreciated). Smaller form and weight and most convenient usability are the important bits for me. Anyone have an opinion to offer?